MovieChat Forums > The Crown (2016) Discussion > Condescending speech she gave to those A...

Condescending speech she gave to those Africans?


I'm not going to go back and quote word for word, but .. When they were on vacation in Kenya or Tanzania prior to her father's death, she gave a speech and came out and said something along the lines "When we (British) first came here, this was a such "savage" place, now with our railroads and electricity, we've made it a nicer. You're welcome"

Is that just an example of the British being British?



Jesus would support Universal Health Care

reply

I like how people think they can say "I'm not PC" and feel it's a gateway to say anything racist. I also like this idea that certain technological advances that occurred in Europe somehow gave them license to exploit and destroy African societies. I'm guessing you are quite unfamiliar with some of the larger advanced and more African kingdoms of the past, before the Europeans began their wholesale destruction, as well.

reply

I also like this idea that certain technological advances that occurred in Europe somehow gave them license to exploit and destroy African societies

Might makes right.
It is one final truth about humanity. If you want something and have power to take it, you will and you will even rationalize what you did to make yourself look like a good guy. Skin color is irrelevant, if African kingdomes had power to do what europeans did they would do it.
I'm guessing you are quite unfamiliar with some of the larger advanced and more African kingdoms of the past

Not advanced enough since they were beaten into submission...

reply

[deleted]

um, this is simply false. And really dumb.

reply

It is an example of the 1950s being the 1950s. Do you have no sense of history?

reply

[deleted]

I know. That speech was disgusting. What about Philip asking the chief where he stole his medals and making fun of another chief's head dress?

reply

Jebus, that faux-pas of Philip's had me gobsmacked and determined to find out if that was fiction or not.
Assuming, for the moment, that it was factual, the African gentleman was dead proud of his medals being recognised and probably (guessing for the moment) won them during the war in East Africa when the British drove the Italians out of theatre.
For Philip to have such a lack of nous doesn't surprise me at all, as he became notorious for his outbursts and oh-so-comical witty repartee (some of that may be ironic).
https://www.irishtimes.com/news/world/uk/you-re-too-fat-to-be-an-astronaut-and-other-off-the-cuff-remarks-by-britain-s-prince-philip-1.3071272

reply

Sure Africa would be great today without Europe's tutoring. See how good it's doing now that it's fully independent. The whole world wants to Iive in Africa.

reply

It was historically accurate language and a sad sign of those times. Hopefully the Queen has evolved and opened her mind in the decades since. Sadly other leaders have recently devolved to using condescending and outright insulting language about African nations.

reply

Just binged the series, and that was an expected view for centuries. Europeans looked down on their colonies as subservient vassal states, whom would have been far worse off had England never Incorporated them into the empire. And while there is a shred of truth to this, it's also a viewpoint of cultural, spiritual and racial domination and superiority that most Europeans were guilty of since the Roman empire.

Not just Europeans. The Chinese still have the same attitude towards the rest of the world, just look at how they officially talk to other nations (an opinion steeped in a three thousand year history, and from once being the "center of the world"). Americans inherited this from Europe, eventually with Manifest Destiny. And ALL people, of all races, generally look at their rivals as less cultured, less intelligent, etc. It's a human condition, that was magnified by European world conquest, and was intentionally placed in the show to detail this history, and how the English looked at their colonies (even though many of them, like Indie, had cultures that far pre-dated the English in history and color).

reply

It might be harsh to say it but its still true.

reply

There's certainly a kernel of truth to it, even if the Brits were often assholes.

reply