What should Germany have done about the Jews

As a Tel Aviv jew Zorty do you approve of the wall round Israel built to as Netanyahu stated 'keep out the wild beasts.'

Isn't it strange how jews are allowed to protect their genetic integrity but if a gentile does it the full force of judaism in all its financial might will crash down on you and crush you.

Do you think your people are going to crush Trump?

Also without your beloved lolohoax do you think you'd have fooled the gentiles to allow infinite brown, blacks and yellows into their nations.

Interesting question that isn't it. It's almost as though the lolohoax has destroyed the European love for their own individuality. Imagine what will happen when the lolohoax becomes well accepted. The white man isn't going to be very happy with the Tel Avivers is he?

No I don't need to try again. You need to have a conversation without pulling the racism card.,


Sometimes you can talk about a group of people simply with an unbiased eye and look at a situation to make a judgement. What the hell is wrong with that?

That's the trouble theses days people are ever ready to hide behind words like racism or anti Semitism making a look at certain issues virtually impossible.

Whether you can accept it or not Jewish interests had an inimical affect on Germany prior to WW2. Why can't you accept this - is it because it is in actual fact YOU who is utterly bias.

No more dead Lannisters
No More dead Trolls

Lmao honest, impartial discussion? As you try to deny a historical fact? Lol yeah, because you're CLEARLY honest and impartial lol... Unbelievable. A sane and logical person would have an honest and impartial discussion, if they thought you had any intention whatsoever of doing the same.

And all you have to do is read any of Tkids posts. That's all the "explaining" I need regarding the crying comment.

I take that back, you're not necessarily trying to deny the Holocaust... but just give some justified reasoning why the Germans did what they did (even though you won't admit it). Which puts you pretty much on the same level of the deniers.

I realise if you mention anything remotely to do with questioning Jews you are labelled anti Semitic or racist.

Here,

Was the entire holocaust about racism, yes and no. For some it was racism and opportunism, while others (much like today in the US) it became a herd mentality driven by fear and false promises, and for others (as pointed out in this movie) it wasn't that easy to say 'no, I won't do it.' You can't simply ask, what should they have done with the Jew's if you do not understand somewhat of the picture. You cannot ask the answer to a question without being willing to pick up some history books and learn every facet of this part of history. Because there is no ONE answer.

If you want even part of the answer you have to be willing and have the respect to read some of this. I don't claim to know everything but I did graduate with a BA in History with an emphasis on WWII Germany and the Holocaust. So I guess my opinion and facts are as good as any as you'll get here.

First you need to understand Hitler's rise to power, the threat of Communism, the failing Weimar Republic put in place by the Allies at the end of WWI, and the feelings that resulted from WWI.

The Treaty of Versailles reassigned German boundaries and assigned guilt (war reparations). This assignment of guilt , as you would figure, lead to anger and resentment. This is one of the parts that opened the door to Hitler

Communism and Russia were a growing threat and the Weimar Republic were not seen to be strong enough to keep them from the boarders. Between the great depression in America in 1929 and their failing support (for more reasons than i can state) the Nazi party (having supplanted the Social Democrats) began to rise in power (sometimes vying with the Communist party). Hitler was made Chancellor of the Schleicher Cabinet with the thought from Hindenberg and the other parties that he and the Nazi party would be one small piece of a larger solution and that he could easily be controlled.

But Hitler's popularity grew as he and his party were seen, by the masses, as an answer for Communism. He was sworn in as Chancellor in 1933.

Prior to this he saw that his racial rhetoric did not gain him ears or votes, and for a time quieted them. When he became chancellor he was able to slowly begin to whip the masses into a frenzy over the 'others' that were taking the jobs and making a profit from war torn germany. He played on these feelings of anger and resentment while promising to bring economic prosperity back to Germany (some of which came from building up their military again gearing for war so Hitler and his party could gain lebensraum/ the territory the nation needed to grow)

But to understand this 'other' concept you also have to understand that there was a distinction between Jews. There were those immigrating and there were German Jews. So while Jews were seen to be taking their jobs and money there were those immigrating that were touted to bring disease and their suffering (looking for that promised land), who only wanted to remain in their insular circles and did not want to conform to the outside world.

The German people needed something less nebulous to blame than the Allies and someone on their soil to get them organized and motivated and of a hive mind. Soon the Jew's were singled out as other, news comics depicted them as rats and the Nazi party began to spout that they were taking up the room that the German people needed to grow, money they needed and more.


[b]How could the Jews be dealt with any other way than they were when an entire population was fed the idea that these people were not human. That they were vermin When you are told and shown that a peoples are not human and are less than-then it is okay to treat them as such.

So when they were carted into ghettos, their homes and businesses taken to be given to Germans. When Germans were also taken from their homes because by the pure blood rule some of them were also Jewish (much to their own dismay), what was there to do but escalate from there? Soon they were out of sight, but still a blight on Germany.

So when the death camps did happen you had people who chose to participate, those who signed the orders, and those who looked away- knowing full well what that smoke and that smell was on the horizon. They knew full well Jew's were being burned

So your question really isn't a simple one at all. You're looking at decades of history where, unless you study it, it seems only the war and the holocaust are looked at. You need to look years and years before to find out how it came to be and why people acted as they did. There is no answer to what should have been done with 'them', we have what is. Greater scholars than I, i'm sure, have taken on this questions but it really cannot be answered in an IMDB posting