MovieChat Forums > The Girl with All the Gifts (2017) Discussion > Millions of people like TWD but this get...

Millions of people like TWD but this gets no love?


I'm completely confused. This is the best thing to happen to zombies since 28 Days Later.

This is the type of story that can you think something like "Maybe you should eat the dog, just do you don't get hungry again." When you start sympathising with a hungry zombie, that's an engaging character.

Walking Dead on the other hand has been on a rinse and repeat cycle for years (not including the introduction of Neegan). Why haven't the millions and millions of zombie lovers who watch that not given this movie rave reviews?

reply

I've never seen TWD. Does it have a similar tone, pacing, etc to this?

reply

No. When it first came on, it was amazing - an ACTUAL ZOMBIE TV SERIES!!! The idea, I gather, was to see what comes next. The films always end with everybody dying or else going off in a helicopter into the sunset, so let's have a TV series which doesn't end then.

Well, what TWD did was demonstrate just why the films end when they do.

There are zombies, so an awful lot of people die due to zombie bites, being eaten and so on.

Then we learn the lesson that we already learned with every zombie film ever made - the living are more dangerous than the dead! ZOMG, it's a surprise every time!

So we have a hard core of original survivors who gradually get whittled down due to zombie bites, zombie dining or evil living people. Occasionally a new character or three joins, and once in a while one or two of them has enough charisma to become a "main" character.

The zombies (called Walkers, or Biters, or Rotters, depending which group we're dealing with - one of the few innovations being the variety of names) become less and less relevant as our regulars confront random bad guys, then the evil-for-evil's sake Governor, then more random bad guys, then some cannibals, then a bunch of people who kill for no reason and have a W carved on their foreheads, and (most recently) the utterly tedious Negan, who singlehandedly lost the series five million viewers.

As hinted earlier, a "main" character is killed from time to time. Unsurprisingly the shock effect diminishes each time. The real kicker, though, is that there isn't anything else. It's literally a case of seeing how long each character lasts before they're inevitably bitten or eaten or murdered.

The Girl With All The Gifts is very different. It has ideas! It has a new perspective on the zombie apocalypse! It has characters with understandable motives. It has interesting imagery, and nice touches such as not knowing which of several zombies will respond to noise.

In short, I've come to love TGWATG (both novel and movie) whereas I regret the time I wasted watching TWD.

This whirlpool's got such seductive furniture
It's so pleasant being drowned

reply

You had me at ZOMG. I have been eyeballing this movie, but keep passing it by. I think I should take a look see now.

reply

I gave up on TWD partway through the most recent series, mainly for the reasons you gave.

I thoroughly enjoyed TGWATG as it appealed to me as a science fiction fan. I almost regret lending it to my brother as I want to watch it again!

This whirlpool's got such seductive furniture
It's so pleasant being drowned

reply

I love almost everything in the zombie genre, but I am watching this movie right now and it is literally rocking me to sleep.

Different strokes, different folks.

That doesn't mean the movie is bad, it's just that I think the zombie genre runs on reflection... it's supposed to be in some way confronting about human nature and the nature of the viewer. For some reason, this isn't doing anything for me (and neither did 28 Weeks Later, whereas 28 Days Later did).

reply

This isn't making you reflect on human nature??? This is probably the first movie to make me ask myself "Do zombie lives matter?" and almost definitely the only show where I was interested in the quest for a cure. It never ever works out, but it's still interesting here to watch these humans survive and try to balance finding a cure for everyone else with their own survival.

I've never seen personal survival vs species survival as an actual theme. Even the "evil Sargent" is a practical real person who you want to survive.

This is hands down, beyond the shadow of a doubt the most mentally stimulating, thought-provoking zombie production ever made. If you're looking for an adrenaline rush, well no, you won't get it here, but this is still an excellent zombie movie.

reply

It didnt make me think any of that, and honestly Im struggling to see where you got it. In the end the girl says some throw away line that amounts to " we have every right to live too", but thats it. What youre talking about is 'I am legend' (the book not any of the terrible movies). That was about what you are talking about. The girl with all the gifts didnt makeme feel anything for her, or any of the feral kids. In fact why the "evil sargent" didnt just shoot all the little fuckers I dont know. They certainly deserved it.

And in the end she dooms the teacher she loves to live in a box. The only person that was ever truly nice to her, and she did that just so she could get stories? In the end being a hungry wasnt the danger, being a little kid with no thought past her own wants is what the danger really was.

So if anything, this was about how children learn from their parents. Its about teaching them even when they dont think they are. In the end the girl locked up a woman she loved as a parental figure. And that was ok to her, because that woman loved her and locked her up. So it was fine. You cold also say it was about a parents inability to let go, and that children will eventually go off to make their own way in the world. But honestly it just wasnt done very well.

reply

Well, IDK about in the UK, but in the US, it's getting zero PR. Most people haven't even heard of it.

reply

Both The Walking Dead and this GirlGift movie are overrated... No where near the kenetic energy, dread and hoplessness of 28 Days Later... also, the former two look like TV, whereas 28 Days Later looks cool

reply

This is not a zombie film. It is very 28 days later esque and the infected are alive just infected with a virus that has taken over their brain. The children are half ''turned''

reply