How does a female blacksmith manage to pick up a heavy sword

The average weight of weapons and tools is now being established with the available equipment that we have at our disposal. But was that the case even then?

That would raise a question. Beowulf is the oldest recorded anglo saxon poetry composed around 7th century during the reign of King Hrothgar[It is currently being debated whether he was an allusion to an actual king]. In the said supposed era, do you think there would be any scientifically accurate measuring tools? Weight would be determined on the nearest possible approximation of the then measuring tools. That said, isn't it only likely that a smith would usually not 'weigh' his hammer, but rather use something that he 'feels' will do the job? Which in turn, would vary from smith to smith. In this case from man to woman.

So logically an average 120lbs female would not wield the same hammer as say, a 250lbs smith? Note not every woman, in any era, would be a Brienne of Tarth.

Im feeling lazy now so I'll let you do the math and point out anything that I may have missed.

reply share

add reply

formatting help

1. The original argument made no mention of the actual smithing of swords

I should think the word Blacksmith would have given you a clue here.

Any blacksmith male or female doing this kind of work would build up muscles over time, but the said actress playing the part was not of a build that could do this kind of job.

It's not just whether she could do this job either. If you look at history through the ages, it wouldn't have been a job a woman would do. Even in the 18 hundreds women were seen as second class citizens who did not do male orientated jobs. After that things started to slowly change, but it took many years before a woman could actually choose what kind of job she would do.

You also have to remember that Beowolf was set a few thousand years before the suffragette movement and votes for women.

reply share

add reply

formatting help