MovieChat Forums > Café Society (2016) Discussion > Judaism does assert an afterlife

Judaism does assert an afterlife


This is a widespread myth accepted by many liberal and/or secular Jews (and even some modern rabbis), and repeated in this film, that Jews do not believe in an afterlife. This is a nontraditional belief. It's true that Judaism is focused on life and deeds, and says little about the nature of the world to come; the practical focus of the religion is not on the hereafter but on the long task of repairing the world to render it worthy of the coming Messiah. That there is more to life than our three score and ten filled with "trouble and sorrow" (Psalm 90:10) is fundamentally inherent.

See the Wikipedia page on Jewish eschatology:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jewish_eschatology#.22The_world_to_come.22

Although Judaism concentrates on the importance of the Earthly world (Olam Ha'zeh — "this world"), all of classical Judaism posits an afterlife. The hereafter is known as 'olam ha-ba (the "world to come", עולם הבא in Hebrew), and related to concepts of Gan Eden (the Heavenly "Garden in Eden", or paradise) and Gehinom.
The article distinguishes between the branches of Judaism; Orthodox, Conservative, and Reform/Reconstructionist. With respect to Conservative:
Conservative Judaism has generally retained the tenet of the bodily resurrection of the dead, including traditional references to it in the liturgy. However, many Conservative Jews interpret the tenet metaphorically rather than literally. Conservative Judaism both affirms belief in the world beyond (as referenced in the Amidah and Maimonides' Thirteen Precepts of Faith) while recognizing that human understanding is limited and we cannot know exactly what the world beyond consists of.
And of Reform:
Reform and Reconstructionist Judaism have altered traditional references to the resurrection of the dead ("who gives life to the dead") to refer to "who gives life to all". Reform and Reconstructionist Judaism affirm belief in the afterlife, though they downplay the theological implications in favor of emphasizing the importance of the "here and now," as opposed to reward and punishment.

reply

>> while recognizing that human understanding is limited and we cannot know exactly what the world beyond consists of.

This is what I really love about Judaism, though I am not Jewish. I like their practicality, pragmatism and realistic views of things like the unknowability of God and the Afterlife ... which is perfect and not over-reaching and obnoxious to force followers to believe in things that might not exist, and then threaten their immortality to squeeze money or conformity out of them. I am sure Judaism has just as much guilt and manipulation as any human group, but if you dig you find something that is beautiful and that does not force people to be conformists to things that do not matter.

reply

[deleted]

Thank you for pointing that out. Keep in mind that most American Jews are Reform, which is more of a fraternity than a religion. A lot of Reform Jews don't even believe in God, they just associate with Judaism as an identity thing.

reply

I'm glad someone brought this up. I'm a (gentile) fan of Allen's films, and have noticed that this is one of his recurring themes/jokes. For example, in "Deconstructing Harry" [SPOILER ALERT] the protagonist finds his father in Hell and pleads for a demon to take him to Heaven; the father then protests that Jews don't believe in Heaven, and asks to go to a Chinese restaurant instead.

Allen claims to be an atheist, but apparently he had a traditional Jewish upbringing, growing up in a religious family that, though hardly orthodox in their practice, did observe the Sabbath, Pesach and other major rituals. I'd say that's probably the belief that is reflected in Allen's consistent references to Jews not believing in an afterlife.

I remember reading something about the word "sheol" in the Hebrew Bible being interpreted as an allusion to an actual afterlife (e.g., by Christians), but also as just a poetical reference to the state of being dead (as in a modern expression like "pushing daisies"). That got me thinking about different branches of Judaism.

Among religious Jews, is there any branch of Judaism that does not believe in an afterlife? Also, does anybody know what branch Allen's family subscribed to?

reply