The second trailer was clearly put together to try to explain what the movie is "about" to people who need to know that. It indeed does a terrible job of selling the movie, because the whole point of the movie is that you can't reduce this stuff to a simple "it's about ..." the way the trailer feels it needs to be reduced.
In fact, all those cliches are either counters to earlier dialogue and hence not cliched in context, or are setups for counters that attack them at least a little.
I'm guessing you made your mind up before the final bit, which is not cliched.
BILLY CRUDUP'S CHARACTER: "Jamie, I also want to say, never have sex with just the vagina, you have to have sex with the whole woman."
GRETA GERWIG'S: "That's slightly off-topic."
The first trailer was risky but hugely better. The first half is intentionally somewhat misleading in tone, with a touchy-feely montage set to Jimmy Carter's "Crisis of Confidence" speech." Which is designed to set up this joke ...
VISITOR WATCHING SPEECH: "He is so screwed. It's over for him."
MOM: "I thought that was beautiful."
[The cultural point being that Carter was 100% correct with the speech, and it indeed killed his chances against Reagan.]
More bits ...
JAMIE: "Stop ... "
MOM: [laughing] "What?"
"Thinking that you know everything that's going on."
"No, I don't ... [more or less sincerely and wistfully] I just think, you know, having your heart broken is a tremendous way to learn about the world."
"Look, wondering if you're happy is a great shortcut to being depressed." (A rejoinder to a cliched "Are you happy?" question.)
These were all big laugh lines. I'll agree that someone who put together a trailer for a comedy that includes just one joke is not doing their job. Extracting the inevitable cliches -- people in real life do use them, and sharp, realistic film dialogue will counterpoint them as I've noted -- is really, really not doing your job.
Oh, and the title is a great title, in that it's sort of very meaningful reference (we learn in voice-over that Bening's character will die just before the end of 1999, after making elaborate Y2K preparations.)
Prepare your minds for a new scale of physical, scientific values, gentlemen.
reply
share