MovieChat Forums > Criminal Minds: Beyond Borders (2016) Discussion > The TRC in South Africa did NOT WORK the...

The TRC in South Africa did NOT WORK the way they are suggesting it did!


The whole point of the TRC (however imperfect or limited it might have been) in SA was that all hearings were held publicly and that perpetrators seeking amnesty had to testify in person in open and give detailed evidence of their crimes.

Overmore, not even 900 out of nearly 6000 applications for amnesty were granted, so the scenario that the show concocted that the TRC would have granted amnesty or given immunity to such a covert group of government sanctioned murderers is entirely incorrect and extremely patronisingto what the TRC was and was trying to achieve!

It was not a perfect process by any means, but it was certainly not a whitewashing of extremely violent, racial, politicised murders either.

reply

I actually enjoyed this episode best of all when it started, but it lost me with its ridiculous portrayal of the TRC. It would have been better if the killers, or the state security forces prior to the end of apartheid, had simply destroyed evidence of their crimes and that there was no way to successfully prosecute them due to the total lack of information about who they were and specifically who they killed or targeted. It would have made much more sense that they simply got away with it during the confusion of the transition. It's not like the NIS didn't destroy numerous records near the end anyway.

The other thing that made me wonder was how are they going to prove who killed the constable? I mean, the only evidence they would have, because obviously the crime was not correctly investigated and I doubt any evidence was allowed to survive, would be the testimony of the pregnant daughter who heard her father's confession while being threatened at gunpoint by a madman. If someone had my child like that, I would confess to the Holocaust to save them. That's also assuming she would even testify or believe that her father was involved and not just saying what the crazy man wanted to hear.

I seriously doubt there would be enough evidence to force extradition or even bring charges. I hate that they had to throw in the fill good of the father getting caught at the expense of any sort of realism.

It was on these two points that the episode really broke down for me.

reply