MovieChat Forums > The Circle (2017) Discussion > I'm a Boyhood supporter

I'm a Boyhood supporter


But Coltrane was the weakest link in that film bar none.

I can't imagine this kid sharing scenes with the likes of Tom Hanks and for that matter, even Emma Watson. He will seem out of place...but maybe that is what is needed for this role.

I'm rooting for the kid, but I just don't see it. Interesting casting decision nonetheless.

reply

Dude, how can you say that?
Coltrane essentially WAS Boyhood, his acting- whether it was the curious boy looking at the clouds, the boy with the shaved hair who had an abusive stepdad, the teen with the fringe and the awkward posture or the teen driving off to college, he epitomizes a generation of 90s kids, situated between the 80s Millennials and 2000s iGeneration. I thought he was really natural in front of the screen, comes across as an incredibly likable person and should have no problem IMO taking on this role.
Boyhoods also my favorite film because I could really relate to him and thought that it showed the 2000s and early 10s incredibly well.
Now, he's gone from a Harry Potter fan in his youth to Emma Watsons girlfriend!
That along with Tom Hanks and the new lead guy John Boyega in the new Star Wars (which he actually talked about in 2008), caps it off- I wish him all the best.

reply

I agree, his character had very little charisma or none, it was like he was forced to read the lines. Come on, him alongside Hanks and Watson? Pfft.

тrυe coυrage ιѕ noт aвoυт ĸnowιng wнen тo тaĸe a lιғe, вυт wнen тo ѕpare one.

reply

Ellar Coltrane is a really talented actor and I'm sure that he will be a very good Mercer, even if his character in the book has nothing to do with Coltrane's appearance.I think that he will have a very good chemistry with Emma...because she's the only one in the film that she is going to have scenes with him.Emma and her on-screen parents.But I can't see a problem if he will share scenes with Tom Hanks or the rest of the cast.

reply