So... Is horror a dying breed?


We have It Follows, The Babadook and The Witch. Three new movies released over the course of two or three years that hold their own among some of the greatest horror films of all time.

The Babadook: A heartfelt exploration into the love a mother has for her son in even the worst of times all against the backdrop of a monster symbolizing her own anxiety and unconscious resentment for her child. It brilliantly tackles the themes of grief, love, family and loss. And is genuinely terrifying without resorting to a single jump scare. There isn't even any gore and the violence is minimal and extremely tame. Rotten Tomatoes rating: 98% IMDb: A mere 6.8/10.

It Follows: A glorious callback to the John Carpenter days. Down to the still cinematography and electronic soundtrack. All while creating an original story concerning morality, fitting in, social norms and paranoia. It covers sex without resorting to gratuity and objectification. And even manages to make the whole act rather scary in its own way. Rotten Tomatoes Rating: 97% IMDb: An unremarkable 6.9/10.

The Witch: An original and atmospheric period piece that builds tension and suspense by the use of subtle filmmaking tactics. The final product here is one of the most unnerving, hellish films ever to exist. All without resorting to any of the modern cliches we've implemented time and time again. It almost seems to not belong of this world, really. Rotten Tomatoes Rating: 91% IMDb: A mediocre 6.7/10.

I'm not one to criticize someone for not liking a movie I love. I believe that every opinion on these matters should be heard. I even have a list on this website that I created a long time ago concerning movies that I believe to be overrated. I truly do respect an individual's view of film. But that doesn't mean I shouldn't be disenchanted by aggregate viewpoints that lists these films as nothing special when they really are. Even if you don't like them, you should at least appreciate how different they try to be. They spark imagination and genuine terror at the things we don't see, instead of pandering to us like children. Since so many people hate these films, does that mean that we actually enjoy being talked down to? How long before horror movies cease to be anything other than manipulative and unoriginal? It's already happening, we just still have a few diamonds in the rough being produced.

This year The Wailing was made, and being a foreign language film, it scared off enough casual viewers to actually garner a good rating on this site. But Hush and The Autopsy of Jane Doe fall right back into the category of "Meh" according to this site.

Sorry for the long post, but I love horror, and it's depressing to see it being treated like this. I could go on and on, but I doubt most of you even made it this far without getting pissed off or bored.

reply

I agree with you on the films you mentioned, I'd even throw more by-the-book horror movies such as Conjuring 1&2, Insidious, Sinister in there as impressive horror movies. Not sure why they're overlooked, perhaps people are turned off by the genre itself.

Who knows, maybe people had the same reaction to movies such as The Shining when they were first released.

reply

I think horror is going through a transition period at the moment. I see a lot of different ideas on what horror is and represents through film nowadays.

I would personally put the first Insidious above both Conjuring movies, Sinister, It Follows and The Babadook. I loved it when the Dad goes into the demons world to save his son.

reply

For me, "The VVitch" is the only horror movie you listed that successfully disturbed me.

The other movies, while great in concept, fail in execution compared to Robert Eggers masterpiece. In my opinion, "The VVitch" out performs every horror movie recently in regards to acting, lighting, tension, screenplay, dialog, score, etc.

The other movies you mentioned aren't bad movies, but calling them the greatest of all time is a bit hyperbolic. I would easily put horror movies like The Shinning, Rosemary's Baby, Psycho far ahead in terms of cinema quality.

Like you though, I don't criticize people for their tastes in something so subjective. You make a good argument for why you like these films so much, and I respect that.

"The VVitch" just hit me harder than anything has in a long time. It surprised, disturbed and transported me in ways other films try but fail.






reply

I don't feel as if I'm being hyperbolic. I truly believe that they are among the best. It Follows may come down to opinion, but The Babadook and The Witch are definitely masterpieces in my book.

And you want to know something crazy? I don't really see what all the fuss is about with The Shining. I still like it, but... It just doesn't make any *beep* sense. And Jack's transformation isn't the least bit scary because he starts off inhuman. I don't know if it's Nicholson's fault or Kubrick's fault, but something went horribly wrong with his character.

reply

Calling the Babadook as masterpiece while criticizing the Shinning makes we want to vomit, but I guess that's just your taste.

reply

Agree with you totally. I'm watching The VVitch as I type & I always find myself on edge, disturbed, & just creeped out! The movie is awesome.

It Follows disturbed me for days on end after I watched that. My husband isn't much for horror, but it bothered him a great deal as well. Love it when a movie has that effect without all the blood & gore.

What site are you referring to where you listed movies? I'd like to check that out..thanks

reply

Are you asking about my overrated list? Because it's on this site. I don't recommend it though, it isn't the most well-written. And it's sure to have some movies that you love on it too. But if you do look through it, don't take my rants too seriously. For the most part, I'm playing up the anger and insults for entertainment purposes.

reply

Great post!! I totally agree! It's distressing to see the younger generation (I guess it must be them?) not appreciating the much more artful way to present a horror film.

I don't think we should fear that the more intelligent or artful horror films will ever vanish though... there'll always be the big dumbed-down moneymakers, but I see no reason there won't also always continue to be "smaller" films. There are plenty of studios and there'll always be plenty of interest in artful filmmaking.

reply

Personally I found The Babadook extremely bad, but hey, everyone's got an opinion, right? Hush was okay, but came off more of a thriller to me than horror. The Autopsy of Jane Doe, I don't know... Decent movie, but not much more.

I do agree about It Follows and The Witch though. I hate horror movies that rely on gore and jump-scares, it takes absolutely zero talent to make something like that. A creepy setting? Yes please. An eerie feeling? Sign me up.

Unfortunately people seem to want exactly those things I/we don't.

Gore can be a useful instrument at times, but movies that rely solely on that to scare you are worthless. Jump-scares are worthless in itself, and is basically the director's way of saying "I can't seem to create an eerie atmosphere, so here's some really loud music all of a sudden".

reply

The genre will never die because it's cheap to produce, and people will always want to be scared.

reply

Great post. I'd add 'The Eyes of My Mother' to the list of recent horror movies that have impressed.

reply

The Witch and The Babadook do not stand among the greatest horror films of all time. Not even close. Just because a horror movie panders to critics by being slow paced and emphasizes drama does not make it great. Nor does a high Rotten Tomatoes score mean a horror movie works as horror.

When I think of the greatest horror movies of all time: Halloween, A Nightmare on Elm Street, The Thing, The Texas Chainsaw Massacre, Suspiria, The Evil Dead, Alien, etc. they are all so much fun to watch. It Follows was very good and one of the best horror movies in recent memory, but The Witch and Babadook are boring as fuck. The Wailing was also pretty good and Autopsy was flawed but the rising action was at least creepier than either Babadook's or The Witch's.

reply

The Babadook was truly horrifying, due to its psychological nature. Boring? I think we saw different movies. That is the most disturbing thing of all.

reply