MovieChat Forums > Cleveland Abduction (2015) Discussion > One Cleveland / West Boulevard perspecti...

One Cleveland / West Boulevard perspective


I had just moved to the neighborhood when Amanda Berry was abducted five blocks from where I lived. I used to drive by the Burger King (where she worked) almost every day on my way to work. Louwana Miller, her mother, quickly made connections with local law enforcement and government officials. The entire neighborhood was filled with posters and ribbons on nearly every pole, bulletin board in businesses, etc. The only reason she gave up was when that snake Sylvia Browne told her Amanda was dead in water. After Louwana died, Beth Serrano, Amanda's sister, kept up the publicity and search.

Gina DeJesus disappeared a year later. She went to school four blocks and went missing five blocks from where I lived. She lived in a different neighborhood and was walking quite a distance but mostly on major roads. People were shocked that she could go missing when her route was so open. Amanda's family was very supportive of the DeJesus family. Gina's posters went up all over, often next to Amanda's.

Michelle Knight had gone missing before the other two, but you have to remember that she was already an adult and had a history of running away from home. Her family life was never healthy. It's true that she was "invisible" to most of us until the day that Amanda broke out and reported Michelle and Gina remaining in the house. In fact, I remember the day that they were rescued: on the radio, the report went something like this: "Amazing news to report this evening: Amanda Berry and Gina DeJesus have been found alive, along with a third woman." Nobody knew about Michelle Knight's plight until her name came across the police scanner, and I think the media wanted to get some background on her before reporting who she was.

It's my recollection and understanding that the FBI and Cleveland Police never gave up the search. I remember when the FBI connected Amanda and Gina's cases and released posters with both of their pictures on one sheet, I think about five years after Gina's disappearance. There were vigils and searches and neighborhood canvassing for them. But it's a big city, and if not for their families, they too would have faded into the background.

I don't know the families or the women but I do know the neighborhood and I can tell you that we were disturbed when the kidnappings happened and shocked to find out that they had been held so close to home. By then I had moved away, but I still followed the searches and stories.

Joshua 1:9 ... unashamed.

reply

It breaks my heart to hear of Michelle's story. Watching interviews with her she is not slow (I reuse to use the R word) like everyone is making her out to be. She's very bright and even Dr. Phil said that after he interviewed her.

reply

She may have some difficulties, but don't we all? I think after 11 years in captivity and the life she had before that, she needed to (re)learn how to present herself in public. It seems to me that she's much more extroverted than Amanda and Gina, and has had to fight for herself for a long time, a combination which led to her not really giving a d*mn in the beginning. In the last two years her presentation has changed, although her message has not.

Joshua 1:9 ... unashamed.

reply

Exactly! We all have difficulties. I think she took on the role of mother type figure for Amanda and Gina and is why she is more extroverted. She went through hell as did Amanda and Gina, but they knew they had people looking for them and Michelle didn't and that monster used this to his advantage.

reply

I never thought that she was slow. Castro beat her with hand weights to the head and the rest of her body. It was so bad that she needs reconstructive surgery. That type of beating is bound to cause damage to the brain. I am guessing that her speech pattern was drastically changed due to the beatings, mental and emotional abuse, and social isolation.

It broke my heart to see what happened to her and the other girls, but I'm so happy that they were all found alive.

reply

How did the FBI come to figure that Gina and Amanda's disappearances were related?

reply

It's hard to find the right language to describe the FBI's approach... They didn't necessarily think the cases were related, but they started investigating them together and considering that evidence in one case might lead to evidence in the other, as I recall. That's when the posters started showing both women together.

Joshua 1:9 ... unashamed.

reply

The only reason she gave up was when that snake Sylvia Browne told her Amanda was dead in water


Unfortunately, too many people really believed in her "predictions" and psychic abilities. This was not the only well-known case she was wrong about but desperate people will grasp at straws when they are looking for a missing loved one or looking for closure with a loved one who has passed on. Thank God Sylvia Browne is not able to hurt anyone else anymore with her ridiculous claims but there are plenty more just like her willing to step up and fill that gap.

I felt so bad for Michelle Knight. She had a difficult time before the abduction and now after the rescue. She is the one who is really strong although the media touts Amanda Berry as being so strong because she is the one who broke free. I feel Amanda Berry is just the most vocal of the three. At least Amanda Berry and Gina DeJesus had strong family ties before and after whereas Michelle is fighting her way back virtually alone. If this movie portrays events as true to life, Michelle was beaten down physically and mentally so much I am surprised she has such a bright outlook now. I am not downplaying what the other young women went through, it just seemed that Michelle may have gotten much worse plus she knew she had no family to return to and rely on. I think what may have gotten her through was the hope of seeing her son when she could be free but even that hope was taken away.

reply

I haven't read the book yet but Amanda supposedly states in the book how she was WATCHING MONTEL when Sylvia said that to her mom and thought to herself how Sylvia was a fraud and she'd like to have a few words with her.

reply

Breaking my ๐Ÿ’ over here.
That effin witch, I never believed her and
I'm sorry Mrs. Berry did.
How dare she & Montel gave her such a large
platform, it was like it was her show instead of his.







๐Ÿ‡ฌ๐Ÿ‡ง๐Ÿ‡บ๐Ÿ‡ธ

reply

Anderson Cooper said it right, Sylvia has no shame.

reply