MovieChat Forums > Florence Foster Jenkins (2016) Discussion > Before William Hung there was Florence

Before William Hung there was Florence


I can't wait to see this.

reply

Susan Alexander Kane!

reply

Your title would be a great tag line for the movie. I hope this is a comedy. I love Meryl.

reply

A fictional character.

She was pushed by her husband's ego and she knew her limitations.

Comparison to Florence Foster Jenkins simply doesn't apply.

reply

Me too! I pray that it's more funny than dramatic. This woman was a hot mess.

Some of us prefer illusion to despair ~Nelson Muntz

reply

Who is William Hung?

reply

William Hung was a guy who auditioned for American Idol. He was awful. But somehow, drew a crowd. All in all he made over a million dollars or so doing performances.
Florence was the same, terrible, but drew a crowd. She was laughed at, but still drew a crowd.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eMNNDJ-zfKI

reply

We had a similar guy in my country, he was a terrible singer but people would still go to his performances.
There's a link to him singing in a tv program: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-UksQ6oljoM
Even if you don't understand the language, you can hear how bad he sings.

🌟

reply

He's still not as bad as William Hung or Florence Foster Jenkins.

reply

The real life Florence Foster Jenkins was a caricature. It'll be interesting to see how they portray her.

Every time our local NPR station had a fund drive (back in the days when fine arts radio actually played classical music), someone would invariably make a pledge and request Florence Foster Jenkins.

Jenkins was a tragically flawed woman, and Streep should be up to the task - provided they give her a decent script.

Meanwhile, there's a French film about Jenkins, titled simply, Marguerite. It came out last year, but I have yet to see it.

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt4428788/

reply

I'm excited about this film too. I've seen a play about Flo, and have a CD of her recordings (can't really listen for very long). What a story -- a colorful part of the rich pageant of human life.

reply

NO ONE can listen to that for very long,at the risk of brain damage.

But they crack me up every time. Lakhme's Bell Song! And that Queen of the Night aria. Like an overwrought chicken who just laid two eggs...

reply

I literally just typed "Before there was William Hung or Wing there was Florence" in response to this on youtube - yes! And if you don't know about Wing, CHECK HER OUT.

reply

Mind-boggling and ear-splitting as Hung and Wing are (and they ARE), they don't hold a candle to FFJ.

reply

If you search for her on Amazon, there is at least on of her albums with previews. People don't believe how terrible she was. The recordings prove it.

reply

Just saw it. The theme is courage. Yes, courage. Florence didn't have the talent but she had the courage to sing in front of people.
- - - - - -
If you don't like the show, stop watching it!

reply