MovieChat Forums > Twin Peaks (2017) Discussion > The one thing I don't like about the Ret...

The one thing I don't like about the Return.


The tulpa thing...weren't dopplegangers enough? What didn't you like?

reply

Im with you on that i think modica. Im gonna wait to see how it plays out, but it has been difficult thinking things are a certain way in twin peaks, and then having to wrap your head around a whole new set of rules. I've probably said this before, i just don't want them getting too "sci-fi" with things. I always enjoyed the more spiritual aspects.

Another complaint....the stupid arm. Now if they had made the arm just a tree that didn't talk, or that whispers like the wind or something, cool, but the arm's voice was stupid and so was that nub hanging from it.

reply

Yeah, 'creative license' and deux ex machina get tiresome sometimes. And I thought the fellas got the idea from The X Files, you know, 'band aid nose man' ? Does put a spin on things though. I though, gee, Diane was murdered? No way an impostor of her is out there is she is still around. But the idea is intrinsic to Season 3 apparently, considering the Red Room action.

reply


I love all of it.


😎


"The owls are not what they seem."

reply