Re: Beth


I find it hard to believe that any righteous parents would let their daughter go out into that kind of weather. It was almost beyond blizzard conditions at that time.

And I'm not sure why everyone is reading ambiguity into the ending. It was very very clear.

reply

Well look at it from their perspective. Sure its snowing hard out, but walking a few blocks in the snow isnt that big of a deal. It would have to be real deep to stop someone from making it on foot. They don't know that the Krampus is coming, so they arent aware of that danger.

Beth and her boyfriend seem like a very clingy high school couple. It seems pretty safe to say that she is going to his house to hang out and won't be going anywhere other than his house.

reply

-I felt the same way. Once she got the go ahead, I thought that was just stupid.

reply

BUT the parents did NOT agree with her leaving... the wife 'gave in' so to speak, and she didn't like it! And after they were each comforting each other that Beth was in a 'safer place' did Max come down and remind them...she'd been gone more than an hour. It was still a stupid decision, yeah, but the Dad was trying to show 'some' faith in his daughter, maybe not safety. And the blizzard hadn't fully "slomphed" down in the Phone Bone(Jeff Smith) 'way' quite yet when she left. It got worse AFTER she left.


3rd generation American from a long line of Gottscheers... it was Drandul, dude!

reply

And after they were each comforting each other that Beth was in a 'safer place' did Max come down and remind them...she'd been gone more than an hour.


He actually mentions that it's dark now, not about the hour that's passed by. But it's a weird scene anyway. Two seconds before that they say she's been gone too long (so they know how much time has passed), while they are sitting in front of the window where they can see how dark it is. Then when Max tells them it's dark and Beth isn't home yet, they look really surprised. Good movie, but this scene was poorly written.

And the storm was decent, but nothing to get really worried about (could be because I'm Canadian though). I probably wouldn't let me 16-17 year old daughter walk through it, but I'd drive her over (this was before the roads were impassable).

There are maybe five beings I hope I never have to fight and J'onn Jonzz is one of them. - Superman

reply

Sure, it was snowing vigorously, but her bf only lived a few blocks away. And they lived in suburbs, not out in the boonies.

America isnt ready for a gay mexican chicken sandwich - Poultrygeist

reply

That wasn't any old blizzard though was it? Could barely see outside.

reply