Beautiful girl, but


her performance is as exciting as cardboard.

reply

I see your point...it is a very understated performance and appears to be rather wooden. But I think this is exactly what the showrunners wanted. Christine is a very aloof and disconnected person. She is not warm, not engaging, and not particularly comfortable around people.

Her cold and surface-level performance matches the show and its themes perfectly.


"This is dead air, Barry....dead air."

reply

Exactly. Also, if you see Riley Keough in her other performances, or in any of her interviews, you can see that she is not anything like the character of Christine Reade. In fact, I didn't even realize she was the same actress as the one who plays Capable in Mad Max, they are so completely different.

What a lovely day!

reply

@Nuxx, I just finished watching Mad Max just a few minutes ago, and Riley Keough was just as flat in her performance in that as she was in this. She has one expression...apathy.

reply

Well, not everyone likes everyone ;)

What a lovely day!

reply

@moviefool09 They are probably trying to copy Sasha Grey's performance which was equally flat, likely due to the fact that she couldn't really act either. I wouldn't call it understated, I'd chalk it up to inexperienced. Elvis was a better actor than her, so is Priscilla Presley. Lisa Marie is likely where Riley gets her flat acting skills from. I am rooting for Riley, she is beautiful, but she needs to develop her acting skills. You can't have a detached flat performance coming from the lead of your show, it won't work, and people will catch on, if they already haven't. I found the Sister, her parents, and, actually, everyone else in the show to be better actors with better performances. The producers are really trying to bolster her with the supporting casts performances, but you can't do that forever. You watch, it will change, it will have to.

reply

I understand your viewpoint, I really do. I think it just depends on how much leeway you give Riley in portraying Christine with such rigidity. I don't think they wanted someone to show emotion. Christine has been described by some critics as a sociopath. I am not sure the showrunners would go that far but they wanted someone primarily to show aloofness, coldness and isolation. To each his own, but I think Riley got across her character very well.

How good of an actress is she? I'm not sure. She's pretty young and presumably will have a lot more work ahead. We'll see if she is able to show more shades. As far as Mad Max, what I mostly remember about that great action film is the action and Charlize's gritty determination in her role. And I've seen it twice. Don't necessarily mean that as a knock on Riley but take it how you will.

"This is dead air, Barry....dead air."

reply

her performance is as exciting as cardboard.

Different strokes for different folks. I suspect nothing will change your opinion. I wasn't impressed with Mad Max either. She had little to do other than look pretty in the background. Didn't even have many lines. But before you write her off in GFE, take another look at Episode 4. That episode gave her the chance to really do some acting.

I posted this in another thread:

She deftly handles a very awkward conversation with Kevin when he tells her he can’t afford her and asks if she can lower her rate because he’s in love with her. She is uncomfortable but remains sweet and smiling and says she’ll figure something out for him. As so often happens in this show, you can see the wheels turning in her mind as she is thinking more than she is saying. Later she coldly tells Kevin that she won’t make any exceptions in her rates.

She has a very realistic sounding conversation with her sister, laughingly making fun of her sister’s comments about a group therapy experience. But she takes on a serious (wooden?) tone when telling her sister she doesn’t like spending time with anyone unless something is being accomplished and uncomfortably telling her sister she’s too busy when her sister wants to spend a few days with her.

With client Michael, she’s sitting in his lap, laughing and sweetly flirting with him.

At David Tellis’ office party, she initially looks uncomfortable, which would be natural for a new intern at her boss’s party. But she loosens up and laughs when David talks with her.

Walking and talking with client Ryan, she chats about her lack of interactions with other people. It’s very similar to what she told her sister and might be the only time she was ever honest with a client when talking about herself. She laughs at his joke but her face conveys an immediate mood change when he says, “I’m F’ing with you. Hey, I’m F’ing you. That’s even better.” Without words, she convincingly looks both annoyed and embarrassed when reminded that these men may act interested in what she has to say but ultimately want her primarily for sex.

Back with Michael, we see her exerting control over their sex encounter and then laughing when his conversation is reduced to telling her about his foot fungus.

Having a drink with Davis Tellis, she is bright and witty.

While saying very little during the call in which Ryan’s wife offers her money to stay away, she is able to use her face, especially her eyes, to show nervousness, followed by defiance (“What if I don’t want your money?”) to opportunism (when offered as much as $20,000). Meeting with the wife to collect her money, she appears cool and collected but afterward shakes so badly she can’t hold her drink.

So while some of the scripts required her to be cold and unemotional, that is not because of the actress. Episode 4 gives Riley Keough a variety of behaviors and emotions to portray. She always makes the scene appear realistic with the right tone or look or mannerisms, often just using her very expressive eyes to give us a clue as to what the character is thinking but not saying.

reply

@FinneganBear, Different strokes for different folks. I suspect nothing will change your opinion. The other actors re making her performance look good. This show won't last very long. @legendofSTu has a great critique and nails exactly what is wrong with the show...and her. Don't get me wrong, I like Riley Keogh, she's very beautiful, but she needs to work on her acting chops. She comes from a long line of bad actors, but is descended from one of the greatest entertainers of all-time, Elvis Presley...incidentally, he only wrote 2 of his songs and needed others to make him look good too.

reply

She comes from a long line of bad actors, but is descended from one of the greatest entertainers of all-time, Elvis Presley...incidentally, he only wrote 2 of his songs and needed others to make him look good too.


The fact that you added that suggests you prejudged her and wanted to be critical because of her grandfather. I was never an Elvis fan. Didn't like his music or his movies. But that has nothing to do with the granddaughter who was born 12 years after he died. She played a character who was unlikable and disinterested because the story called for it. It was not a happy character or an exciting story with car chases and explosions. It was a character study. What impressed me was how she sold every line with her eyes, voice inflections or mannerisms. She made the character seem realistic even if it was a character the viewers were not inclined to like.

reply

@FinneganBear,

The fact that you added that suggests you prejudged her and wanted to be critical because of her grandfather.
Nope, that does not prove that I prejudged her in anyway. In fact, it is the opposite of prejudgement, why? Because I added it to my critique...after the fact and it paints a clearer picture of why she is not a very good actress. As a model, you can get away with that bored look, which is what she was before this. Lisa Marie is has the same look on her face too, it's genetic: http://www.aceshowbiz.com/images/wennpic/wenn3185613.jpg

sold every line with her eyes, voice inflections or mannerisms
Nope. She emotes about as much as river rock..boring, emotionless, numbing. http://leroyschroeder.com/wp-content/gallery/river-rocks/Colorado-Rainbow-River-Rock-2-Inch.jpg

And just like river rock needing a river to be interesting, Riley needs a strong supporting cast, which they've given her:

http://media-cache-ec0.pinimg.com/736x/8d/15/ec/8d15ecef351788edc4dab427d1ca9894.jpg

She's sleepwalking through this role.

http://www.serienjunkies.de/news/review/75054-keough.jpg

reply

I agree with this post completely. I gave up on the show after episode 4 because I felt like I was wasting my life watching a dead eyed robot sleepwalk through her performance. I get that it's supposed to be some depressing artsy take on prostitution but I find it incredibly hard to believe someone would pay 5k to have sex with a depressed mannequin. I don't think she is just "that good at acting", I think she is just painfully boring and the creator finds depressing lifeless characters intriguing for some reason.

reply

@LegendofStu, Great critique. I agree. Right on.

reply

She is playing a person devoid of emotion and feeling, so maybe what you see as a flaw in the performance is how the character is to be played.. I think she did an amazing job. In fact, she just won a Golden Globe for her performance.

reply

Check that: she was a GG nominee, not a winner.

reply