MovieChat Forums > Z Nation (2014) Discussion > Battle of the zombie survivors: Z Nation...

Battle of the zombie survivors: Z Nation vs TWD vs DOTD vs Zombieland

posted 8 years ago by conanyouredevilish
4 replies | jump to latest

The zombie survivor groups from the following movies/TV shows of Z Nation, The Walking Dead, Dawn of the Dead (remake) and Zombieland battle until one group is still standing. That's basically the storyline for Walking Dead now these days isn't it? Which group is left standing in the end? Which group would you rank from best to worst?

I'm going to expect The Walking Dead fans to be claiming the characters from their show is the best and anyone of them can single handily kill any of the other groups as I've seen from other sites. Oh please, those characters can't stop doing stupid things and getting their teammates killed in every turn. Sometimes the plot is reliant on them being idiots. Heck haven't some of TWD characters accidentally killed some of their own teammates? Guardian angels clearly exist in that show too as that's the only reasonable explanation for the immense character shields the "unkillable" characters have being able to survive every situation they moronically get themselves into. Then again those other sites the average user doesn't seem to have intelligence beyond that of a 5 year old, so maybe we'll at least see some reasoning in this thread.

[–] gtboy1106 8 years ago

I would say z nation season 1 group is the best survivors but they lack building and growing senses... zombieland are leaches they use everything up and talk non stop with a legit plan... the walking dead are true survivors until someone gets crazy but at least they try to build until some outsider gets crazy lol

[–] GreenEarthBlackSky 8 years ago

Definitely the Z Nation group. Murphy could just control all the zombies and have them attack the other groups full force.

[–] mistersparkle 8 years ago

Doesn't matter. Whoever's left at the end gets taken out by Peter from Dawn of the Dead (original), lol

Zombieland shouldn't even be in the running if it's a real fight. The girls only get by with looking helpless and tricking men, something these other groups ain't gonna fall for (cept maybe 10k and Caruhl) the guys, they're just lucky.

I don't remember Dawn remake having any good fighters, and they have that dumb girl dragging them down worrying about the dog so much. Either of the other two groups could easily take them. Well, if they didn't already get eaten at the end of their movie.

So it comes to Z-Nation vs Walking Dead, and unless you've got Murphy using a horde of walkers to over run Rick and co, (and you know how uncooperative he can be), the Walking Dead crew just has too many experienced fighters with them. Roberta is all the Nation has in that regard, vs Rick, Abraham, Rosita, even Tara has military training. The Nationers put up a decent fight but the numbers and experience just gives TWD's crew the edge, Murphy's magic tricks aside.
--
You have many question, Mr Sparkle. I send you premium -- answer question, hundred percent!

[–] conanyouredevilish 8 years ago

Zombieland shouldn't even be in the running if it's a real fight. The girls only get by with looking helpless and tricking men, something these other groups ain't gonna fall for (cept maybe 10k and Caruhl) the guys, they're just lucky.

Zombieland crew is the only one here who had all their members survive from beginning to end. They definitely were pretty smart and cautious seeing Eisenberg even has his whole "rules to survive a zombie apocalypse" list that he kept on bringing up. Plus Woody and Jesse was expecting Emma and Abagail and the girls still managed to successfully jump them.

I don't remember Dawn remake having any good fighters, and they have that dumb girl dragging them down worrying about the dog so much. Either of the other two groups could easily take them. Well, if they didn't already get eaten at the end of their movie.

None of these teams have any remarkable good fighters. With these kind of teams, all that really matters is being able to use a weapon and not doing anything dumb, and it's pretty well known by a number of users here that the words "The Walking Dead" and "common sense" don't go hand in hand. BTW Ving Rhames is superior in combat to anyone on Walking Dead.

So it comes to Z-Nation vs Walking Dead, and unless you've got Murphy using a horde of walkers to over run Rick and co, (and you know how uncooperative he can be), the Walking Dead crew just has too many experienced fighters with them. Roberta is all the Nation has in that regard, vs Rick, Abraham, Rosita, even Tara has military training. The Nationers put up a decent fight but the numbers and experience just gives TWD's crew the edge, Murphy's magic tricks aside.

For "experienced" people it's amazing how the Walking Dead crew fights the weakest zombies, and loses the most people. There's no way that level in ineptitude isn't going to cost them like it does every single season.