MovieChat Forums > Z Nation (2014) Discussion > Ok, Murphy has to die this season

Ok, Murphy has to die this season


Honestly it's getting old. We've been chasing Murphy for 2 seasons now. They need to end this arc and develop a new one. The writing of it is extremely atrocious. Murphy's character is all over the place. At some points you start to think that he's finally developed into something more than a selfish manchild. At the end of season 2 and several moments before the final episode he seemed like he geniunely saw the group as friends. Yet every single time this development is undermined because Murphy just HAS to play the villain because there is noone else available. It's boring now just kill him. Season 3 Murphy already feels like season 2 Murphy all over agaun.

But I suppose i'm expecting too much, the writing is all over the place period, and not just with Murphy. Like the flashback movie. I'm completely convinced that entire movie existed to retcon certain things within the plot. For example, what Murphy's bites do to people. In season 2 we saw a savage Cassandra who needed z weed to "feel", yeah she smiled at 10k a little once, but overall she was a cannibalistic animal who was basically Murphy's hooker with how infatuated she was with him. Now suddenly in the flashback film she's saving 10k's life, the same guy whose neck she tried to snap. Now suddenly bitten people are completely free thinking humans who can be defiant, just under his control. What? was Cassandra's mind not strong enough to break through his zombie force powers?

reply

Well, if they kill him off, the main plot point goes out the window, which is someone carrying a possible cure. There would be no more mission. Now, if his daughter were be as valuable, she would make an interesting replacement, especially as she seems to be growing rapidly. It would be especially funny if she turned out to be as much a prick as her father.

reply

No. Murphy is the whole reason for the show.
And you don't get it; MURPHY SEES THEM AS FRIENDS, THEY DON'T. Watch episode 214 again, when he is scared out of his mind about going to the CDC and he turns to Warren and ask her to let him go. "If you were really my friend, you wouldn't do this..."
And Warren replies "I'm not your friend." Then going on a rant about she knows Murphy is going to get hurt but she doesn't care.

He is selfish because no one that he is traveling with sees him as anything other than a package that needs to be delivered. Even when he tries, he still doesn't get anything for it. in 108 he could have left them all at the morgue, but came back to save them. Only to have them turn him over to Kurian at the end of the season. Who wouldn't be selfish at this point. Murphys character is about what we as humans do to eachother during a crisis. We are willing to sacrifice one of our own to save ourself.

As fo the biting. When Murphy bit Cassandra, she was half dead. There was nothing left of her, therefore he was able to controll her in a different matter. The others have all been healthy people (10K has some blood loss but whatever) so they keep more of their own mind. Cass was more Z than human, while Merch needs to be lucid in order to create a virus to spread the blends.



X ~We are the people our parents warned us about

reply

I agree. Murphy is my favorite character, and Keith Allan is fantastic in the role.

reply

Love Murphy! He is the best, they better not kill him off because he makes the show, he is charismatic, funny and relatable. Never really cared much for Warren, maybe in the very beginning she had potential, but she has shown exactly why Humanity failed. I like 10k but now like him even more that he is with Murphy. Doc is also ok and Citizen Z and the Eskimo crew too but the rest of Bitemark humans i can gladly do without.

reply

Except you're absolutely wrong. You're the one who needs to rewatch episodes. Countless times the rest of the cast have considered him a friend only for him to flip the switch on them. He's done it with Doc, 10k and Warren. It seems like every other episode they have to yet again explain to him the situation and make him understand. He seems to understand, only to later betray them once again. They all considered him a friend at the end of last season. That didn't stop him from once again flip flopping on them forcing them to yet again retaliate. They keep thinking less of him because HE keeps giving them a reason to. They're trying to save humanity, and he's always coming up with a way to damn it all, and play "king".

Even 10k was once friendly with him in the episode where he got them food, and then in the next episode Murphy ruins it. Warren did not go on a rant about not caring if he got hurt. You're taking what she said out of context. She explained to him that she could not promise he wouldn't get hurt and she also explained that noone in this story has a happy ending and that they all will get hurt. Sound advice, Murphy is just a manchild who ultimately cares about noone but himself and the baby. You see that much when he basically reduced Cassandra to his back massaging attack dog and his now torturing of 10k who clearly would rather jump to his death than be Murphy's slave, Murphy knows this, and still he insist on toying with people. He's treated like a monster because he IS a monster, even before they experimented on him you see this when he closed the door on the other prisoner to protect himself.

reply

" . . . he IS a monster, . . . you see this when he closed the door on the other prisoner to protect himself." I suspect it was the average character traits of criminals that prompted the choice of his situation prior to being experimented on. Can you imagine if they took Average Joe Family Man away from his lovely wife and 2.3 children and turned him into a nasty, self-centered, almost zombie? It would have messed up the entire story because viewers would have been sympathetic to Average Joe.

Sorry, but the old lady had to put down that thought while it was still with me. As for the rest of the ideas in this thread, I personally, think they're being viewed incorrectly. Throughout the show, we've had hints and clarification that Murphy is constantly undergoing changes due to the virus even if he's not a complete zombie. Besides, turning blue and developing an aged leather look to his skin, during the 3 years of this show, I'm quite certain that everyone watching the show and reading this forum have also undergone some changes, some more significant than others. I do have a sympathy for those who are struggling with physical disease or problems because it certainly does affect your personality - add to that whatever environment you find yourself in and there are times you feel like your bouncing off walls with the ups and downs and might be heading towards turning blue yourself (or is that just me? tee hee hee!). But, back to the universe of Z Nation - we've seen physical changes as well as emotional and personality changes - sometimes making sense, sometimes they just are.

Then in S03E04 (sorry, I'm not able to keep up with these like you younger folks are - Shucks, Ok, you showoff kids shamed me and I had to go back and confirm what I was claiming here. Good thing I did, since the conversation was not with 10K but Murphy himself and there was no reference about Patient Zero eating brains . . . ) we heard Dr. Merch talking to Murphy about the changes that happened to the first victim of the vaccine, she even called him Patient Zero. First, Murphy admitted that there were times when he had no pep and was just dragging, then he said sometimes he felt himself slipping away and becoming one of them. That's when she explained that he needed the booster shot, not to feel human again, but to feel less dead. That's a pretty radical change that he has no control over! Because of this conversation, I was not at all surprised to watch Murphy being tempted by the availability of Merch's fresh brains in E05. The situation with this Patient Zero is different from Murphy's so I don't believe that Murphy will have to die just because Patient Zero did. Murphy basically lived his human life as a selfish, manipulative, cold-hearted person and now he's mostly doing the same as someone who is progressively becoming more zombie all the time.

Your example of 10K being friendly when Murphy got them food, goes as a good example to what I'm saying. When things are going good for us, it's much easier for us to be kind, considerate and even to tolerate those we don't particularly care for. Any person, even without the vaccine or the virus, tends to be drawn towards acting like those people they are around most often. If it's a friendly, easy going group - we'll respond in kind - it doesn't really mean that our core personality has completely changed or has changed permanently, it's just the way we're built. However, during times of illness, unwanted changes, or simply unpleasant or stressful times, most people end up reverting to being like they've been most of their lives so no one should really be surprised to see that happen - virus or no virus.

I've actually been pleasantly surprised by this show and how they have killed off main characters even though I've liked those characters, but I'd be really surprised to see them kill off Murphy - too much of the story surrounds him and he does an excellent job playing the character - IMO. So, I can easily imagine seeing the dynamics of the group radically changing if Lucy were to come live with her father and he rejoins the group, but I really can't imagine Z Nation without Murphy - at the end of their run, sure.

Oh, someone tried to say that it was out of character for Cassandra to stop 10K from sacrificing himself near the end of the flashback episode this season. Although I can't be as helpful as most of you and give you exact references, I do recall watching Murphy indicate to Cassandra, either with a simple nod of his head or with a command, to go with and protect another character - sometimes to the displeasure of the person that Murphy was sending her to "help" - they didn't want her help. I've always assumed that just because they didn't use the time to show Murphy specifically ordering Cassandra to rescue 10K, doesn't mean that she was actually thinking on her own - now that idea would be a surprise to me. If there was one character that I really didn't mind losing, I guess it would have to be Cassandra, but she was entertaining once in awhile and useful to the story.

Anywho. those are just my thoughts on this thread. Now we'll just have to watch and see how it all comes out!

Shauna & Ms. Phoebe, my God-given Happy Pill

reply

phantom_pixie, it's truly refreshing to read someone like you who truly "gets" the show!! 😀

reply

Absolutely. Team Murphy all the way I always felt bad for Murphy the way he was treated form day 1 was appaling., imo Warren has to die next, most of the humans have showed exactly why Humanity failed in the 1st place and Warren is now the best example. I love that 10k is now "reformed" bc i really like(d) his character but not when he was with the Bitemark idiots. They have a new Villian the " Man" to me Murphy was never a Villain he was a Victim, that has made a tremendous Journey and is now kicking ass.

reply

McGuffin can't die. I mean, Murphy.

reply

I kind of agree that Murphy is getting old, and I don't think the show needs him. They have all these vaccines from his blood, or could theoretically manufacture them. They could kill Murphy off, and still have the possibility of a cure, or of giving someone else Murphy-like powers.

reply

If Murphy dies then I will stop watching. He is what keeps me watching.. I loved his character since episode one.

I do like the other characters, but I don't think they'd be enough to keep me interested. Unless the creators decide to cast someone as equally as good as Murphy is (or somewhat similar), then nah.

reply

Exactly! Next on the chopping block should be Warren, she becomes increasingly embarrassing for "Humanity", how can I root for humanity while she has this a-hole attitude, she was always so mean to Murphy, saw him more as an object then a human being, same as Addy, why do they make the women on this show so obnoxious is beyond me. Same with the Asian Solidier women, at least she somewhat showed some empathy in the recent episodes and redeemed herself. Oh and we have Kaya she is supercool, still sad that Cassandra is gone i liked her allot also as Zombie. Oh well they won't kill Murphy, if they are half smart. They probably off the "Man" as he is now the Villain and he already had 9 lives. But i really hope Warren and Addy's days are also numbered.

reply

I think you mean strong, not obnoxious. All the women are strong and intelligent. Warren has, at times, shown a lot of sympathy for Murphy and so has Addy, despite the fact that it was his fault Mack died. Sun Mei (your "Asian Soldier woman") is not used to the group and is still getting to know everyone.

Bear in mind that nobody wants to be a bad person. Nobody is a villain in their own story. Murphy is human, so is Warren and both sometimes do some things that they may regret. This is what makes Z Nation so compelling and the characters so real.

Look at it this way. Z Nation has a character who eats human brains and enslaves people and he still manages to be a relatable character with a lot of warmth and humour.

I think you dislike the female characters because they are not soft, feeble bimbos. A lot of people don't like female characters who act like real people. One of the things I like about Z Nation is that every character is doing their best and every character sometimes gets it wrong. When a disaster happens, like the loss of Lucy, the team unites and there is genuine affection between them.

reply

Physical strength is not the same as mental strength or intelligence. While Warren and Addy are physically capable, they are lacking empathy and progressive thinking. Warren is holding on to a concept that is dead, repeating patters (using others for "the greater good") that lead to humans downfall = Z Nation in the first place. Addy is just Warrens Lapdog.

Murphy is relatable to me, because in his situation I would have a similar mindset. He does not want to enslave people, he wants to protect them, help them to live free of fear, adapting to the new Age of Z Nation. He doesn't constantly control everybody, they follow him willingly because they feel safe in his presence and have hope for a future of peace. There are exceptions of course the doctor lady for example, but in all fairness all those doctors used Murphy as a Lab rat from day 1. No love lost here.

He eats brains..., well in Z Nations day and age I would consider this like eating beef, bacon or eggs. Animals are living breathing beings too, but humans slaughter them without hesitation and if that wasn't enough, in the industrialization of the animal agriculture they are treated like objects. Yet just a fraction of people see it as a problem. Animals feel pain and joy, they bare children, they live in families, just like us, yet some humans just decided that they are superior and therefore enslave them and eat them. Gross.

Besides that Murphy didn't want to eat the brains, he was fighting the urge, even though it seems to be in his "nature" now and he is benefitting from it as he can literally eat the persons knowledge.

Being kind, smart, emotionally sensible isn't negative, it's exceptional. Additionally you can be headstrong as long as you stay open minded.
But being a brute imbecile like Addy and Warren isn't sparking admiration from me.

Hopefully I made it clear enough know what I think, so you don't have to speculate anymore.

reply

I dont think murphy has to die this season or ever in the show. The shows runs on the premise that the experimental vaccine given to murphy hold some cure to ending the zombie like in the movie z nation where brad pitt injects himself with a disease and the zombies ignore infected people.

I could see murphy dying in the show, especially if they show them going up against zona. Say this show goes for 4-5 seasons. We could have them introduce zonas base at the end of this season. Fight and victory against zona in season 4, season 5 we can have murphy die naturally from the experimental drug like patient zero or have some survivor of zona kill murphy then end the series with humanity getting back on track.

reply

Murphy's character is all over the place. At some points you start to think that he's finally developed into something more than a selfish manchild...yet every single time this development is undermined


Totally agree, just when you think he has gone a little deeper, they just use him as a contrivance to suit whatever plot device they need setting up next!


I also totally agree about them changing what his bite/spit does to people was short-sighted initially, and they had to go back and re-do a lot to give themselves more options for the future. That's the biggest sign of poor writing there to have to rehash things that already happened so they can change the future plot lines. Really Bad.

Most of us are pretty much just looking for a fun Zombie romp with a story that makes sense and some fun and endearing characters... But it seems even that is too much to ask this season!

They seem to have got to a place where the series went longer than they anticipated and they got themselves stuck and so had to change their own backstory to create a very thinly stretched plot moving forward.


Riddle wrapped inside an enigma, wrapped inside a taco.

reply

Well, give 'em a break. This is The Asylum's first TV series. I enjoy it. Sometimes SMH enjoying it, but...

***Ignorance isn't bliss. Ignorance is laziness. So stop being so lazy!***

reply

OP I think Murphy will die, people will vaccinated by him will be freed and then his daughter will mature and take them over.
If I were a writer that's the best way to keep the show not just alive but FRESH for at least 5 years, however, I think if they kill him in the right way and bring her in the right way with accelerated growth due to the disease, this might be a 7 or 8 season show.

The writers behind this really thought it out through research and imagination.
Best idea for a zombie production I've ever seen right down to his blue skin breaking down.
Incredible show with brilliant psychology behind it.

reply