I have not given up hope for RZ.
Over all, I think there's a lot to like here, even if nothing is new to the genre. I detested Halloween 2 and Lords of Salem (and believe me, I tried like hell to like them). House & Rejects are a couple of the best horror films ever, and for different reasons, which adds to their brilliance. This one doesn't compare, but it didn't suck either.
The dialog was inconsistent. At times, like when Doom's Head was monologueing, it was great. Also liked Sick Head's rambling English/Spanish, it was the right amount of camp and genuine scariness. BUT! the talk btwn the captives during the "down time" was really lame. Almost excruciating. Couple that with terrible acting, and yep, he's got some problems.
The murderers were interesting. The old freaks in charge of the game were interesting (Judy from To Sir With Love!!). I particularly liked the lack of backstory. The most boring characters were the victims. Meg Foster was criminally under-used, considering that she is the only really good actor of that bunch. And Lawrence Hilton-Jacobs with that horrendous accent! Really cheapened it. And as much as I would love to hang out with Sheri and parrrrtay, she was not particularly convincing, either. Her looks make up for it, though. I could watch that girl sleep. Whoo.
The violence was exceptional. The cinematography was spectacular; the spaces looked incredibly real. I love his attention to quirky detail.
I fully expected to be annoyed by Zombie's pathological use of profanity. I didn't think this was that bad. I also expected a rape scene (he seems to like them) and was relieved that there wasn't one.
So yeah, not his best, but better than his worst. I'm still a fan.