I was really looking forward to this, I had read such good reviews, one from mark Kermode who's judgement I usually trust, .. I bought the Blu Ray HD disc for most of the film to be blurred !! .. I found the way it was filmed quite irritating ... and Saul started to annoy me after a while ... all that going on and he was obsessed with finding a rabbi to bury that boy !!
Overall very dissapointed
If you want to see a good film about the holocaust I recommend another Eastern European film 'Fateless'
Your post just proves you've never gone through anything traumatic in your life, so congratulations on that. First, it's filmed the way it's filmed for a specific purpose-we are to be with Saul the entire movie, and see what he sees. We as viewers are supposed to be Saul. It's a narrow viewpoint-hence, the blurriness. We see what Saul sees and hear what he does, nothing else. In a place where you have absolutely no control, where you could die any second for any reason, literally face to face with death and destruction of your own every single day, I don't think it is unlikely for someone to have wanted to control what little they could, and Saul felt that he could give this boy a proper burial and he was going to risk everything to do it. There are stories of those who committed suicide in the camps for the same reason-because they could at least control their own death and not die at the hands of the Nazis. We don't know Saul's history or even if he had/has a son, but we do know that Saul is a compassionate human being, even in the midst of the merciless inhumanity that were the concentration camps.
You didn't really need to point any of that out Buck. It's all self-explanatory. None of you what say prevents the film from being a disappointment, from the style being irritating or the lead character being annoying.
As for the original post, putting your faith in Kermode is where you went wrong. Kermode is swayed by personal politics and preference when it is a critics job to be objective. He's a champion of Minions, Twilight, Highschool Music and Transcendence for heavens sake.
I have been through plenty of traumatic things in my life .. I spent 9 months in hospital after a life threatening incident when I was 2 for example, but nothing that has happened to most of us can compare with the holocaust, but like the next poster says it doesn't stop it from being, in my opinion, an irritating film .. but as i say that is only my opinion
Well, good is in the eye of the beholder. I think the Fateless film you mentioned is Sorstalanság, also a Hungarian movie. I didn't like its Nobel winning book that much, but the only thing I can remember from that film is that the children acted very poorly. I very much prefer Saul.