Adopted Brother


Wouldn't his adopted brother be pissed off at his portrayal in this film?

reply

Probably

reply

I wonder if mandu had some kindvof aspergers or mental issues especially when he hits himself.

reply

From working with special needs kids id say definitely autism with the added delight of trauma. Broke my heart to see his scenes, and the kid in the orphanage with similar issues.

reply

I was trying to figure out what was the matter with the kid also. I figured it had to be autism.

reply

I underdstand it was Saroo's story but the way they left things with Mantosh left a lot to be desired. He didn't even get his proper due and his last meaningful scene was the tantrum at the table... thought he deserved a better ending, at least in the end credits they could have mentioned something about him.

reply

The end credits had pictures of Saroo and Mantosh interacting lovingly as children but yes there could have been more positive adult images.

reply

On Facebook, look up Mantosh Brierley. It seems he hasn't posted since December, at which time he informed a friend he was very unhappy with Saroo making him look like a druggie. He mentioned nothing about behavioral issues, only substance abuse. He was having a hard time and ashamed to enter rehab, so was taking a time out. Since he seems not to have posted since the film was widely released perhaps it brought up serious issues and the best hope is that the exposure results in some positive help and improvement in his life.

I must admit to identifying with Mantosh. Few things are more provoking than having a perfect brother--one need read the Bible no further than Genesis to come up with two great examples--not only adored by the parents but handsome, and now rich and famous as well! I have two perfect sisters, and have long known whereof I speak. As a kid you keep hoping to make things turn out favorably, but being shown up badly enough as an adult must give one pause. The scene where an adult Saroo destroyed poor Mantosh in only five words was amazing. Having everyone look at you as the one who didn't turn out is a perfect recipe for meltdowns and a very good reason to avoid human interactions.

reply

a lot of insight there. thanks.

reply

Is he really an autist in the original novel???

reply

[deleted]