MovieChat Forums > Lion (2017) Discussion > The saddest part..

The saddest part..


The big brother died

reply

Pretty sure the saddest part is Nicole Kidman's pathetic efforts at staying 20-something.

reply

Why the hate? She looks great for her age. Astrological Gemini youth genes :D

reply

I've been a fan ever since I saw her in BMX Bandits.

She is a natural beauty that has no business trying to keep up with the young starlets.

She'll get work regardless.

I just hate some of the photos I've seen of her where she looks ridiculous.

reply

Natural beauty full of botox.

reply

Pretty sure the saddest part is Nicole Kidman's pathetic efforts at staying 20-something.



I don't think she was supposed to be 20-something in the film.

reply

Saroo's adoptive mother said in an interview that she waited sixteen years for her kids so even if she married at 20 that would make her 36.

reply

For me it was the end...When the real Saroo introduced his two moms to each other I felt that moment was very powerful and it was filmed well.

~What if this is as good as it gets?!~

reply

THIS. I could literally feel my heart swelling. I was crying before but at that moment I started audibly sobbing lol

reply

I thought the bit where the kids start singing in the orphanage after that one kid gets taken out was pretty sad, some of them would have had no prospects in their future at all

reply

That was very poignant, yes. The children still had hope.

Brideshead is A Thousand Moments and MacBeth

reply

What happened to Guddu? The text disappeared too fast for me to read it. I just saw that he had died that night.

Brideshead is A Thousand Moments and MacBeth

reply

You had to be quick to catch it -- the same evening as Saroo disappeared, he was hit by a train. While watching the movie, I imagined that the mom may have blamed Guddu for Saroo's disappearance, but that never happened.

reply

Thanks.

reply

What happened to Guddu? The text disappeared too fast for me to read it. I just saw that he had died that night.


Guddu, His older brother told Saroo to wait at the station for him, but he was hit and killed by a train, which was why he never returned for Saroo.

From what I understand, his body was found in two pieces.

From Wikipedia:

In the meantime, his mother, Kamla Munshi, searched for her two sons. A few weeks after her sons failed to return home, police informed her that Guddu's body had been found near the railway tracks, a kilometre from Burhanpur station. He had been struck by a train.

reply

Same here! My heart broke and I was aching so much for him when I learned that his brother died on the same night! I could only imagine the anguish their mother must've felt all those years—first in losing both her sons; then learning the eldest son was dead, and probably thinking the other was too; and then finally having her youngest son in a way return to her from the dead after all that time! Perhaps his older brother's last concern or thought was for his younger brother and for him not to suffer a similar fate as he and that's why Providence sent him to Australia for his ultimate preservation not unlike the Biblical Joseph being sold into slavery in Egypt.

reply

Thing is, Guddu at least never lived to feel the guilt of losing his little brother. That much was a relief to me, because they were playing it up that he spent all those years wracked with guilt over losing his brother when he had taken him along with him to work.

For me, this part wasn't the saddest part, but the part which made me cry was seeing the real life footage of Saroo's mothers meeting. It still puts tears in my eyes thinking of such an emotional meeting.

reply

I agree that the brother being dead was the saddest for me...the next being him first seeing his natural mother again

reply

All of the above. The parts that especially got to me however, were minor scenes, but effective, thanks to Sunny Pawar's natural performance:

- The scene with the spoon. The kid's face when he motioned that he was hungry was so genuine, it was touching.

- The scene where he gets run over by the scooter, and he runs home bleeding.

- The final scene where the brothers were playing on the tracks. Once again, genuine, and touching.

reply

Really? I thought dis wuz a comedy and wuz lolin entire time

Werd 2 ur mudda, bruddafckka

reply