I suppose that Emma Tregirls, daughter of Tholly, was a bit of an outsider and exotic to Sam. She also has a mind of her own. Sam is attracted to Emma and though he couches that attraction in conventional terms, it is physical. He hopes to convert her to Methodism and marry her to legitimize his strong physical desire.
If I remember, in the novels Emma was a buxom brunette. She also had a reputation mostly undeserved as a loose woman. While she admitted to permitting liberties: necking and petting, she told Sam that "No man has had me". She is principled in her own way, and though she comes to love Sam deeply, she is clear-eyed and realistic. She 'could never conform to Sam's devout Methodism. no matter how much she loves him.
Emma leaves the village and takes a job elsewhere as a housemaid, eventually sadly asking a friend to write a letter to Sam (Emma is illiterate) informing him that she will marry a footman who is employed where she is who loves her and with whom she sees a chance of a solid marriage of equals.
Rosina Hoblyn is a sweet biddable girl whose advantages as a wife, Sam comes to realize, and he eventually marries her.
reply
share