Unfortunately disappointing
I won't say I hated it, and I will probably watch it again sometime, but it really didn't meet my expectations which were managed to begin with. I knew it wasn't going to be Coscarelli and I knew that corners would be cut in the budget department, but I expected something that had a bit more resonance (Phantasm pun there) and had a bit more charm. I also knew the end would be a bit of a cliffhanger, Phantasm style, but this just felt like it was chopped off without much consideration. The after-credit scene was pretty cringe-worthy and I wish they hadn't added it even though I liked seeing Rocky again. Overall the effects weren't uncharacteristically terrible (I mean, effects have never been the strongest part of Phantasm). The Tall Man was cool, as always, although I would have liked him to have more screen time. I kinda liked the different timeline aspects, feeling like they were doing a nod to Coscarelli's other work Bubba Hotep with Reg being in the nursing home. It starts getting very haphazard in the way it switches back and forth towards the end though. It seemed like they didn't have much of a plan. Ultimately, I guess I just wish they had a bit more interaction with the Tall Man and had devised a more clever ending. I gravitate towards feeling that if this is what we get then it's better than nothing, but at the same time I don't feel like it added much if anything to the canon. I am probably in the minority in that I think the 4th movie is the best of the sequels and love how it ended. I was hoping this would at least do something to expound upon that but it really didn't.
share