Lombard's accent


His character was supposed to be Irish? His accent sounded more American.

reply

If And Then There Were None were an American film, the producers could probably get away with Aidan Turner playing an English character. But it was made for British TV and for most Brits it's screamingly obvious that Turner is Irish from the moment he opens his mouth that they simply changed Lombard's nationality.

reply

Aidan Turner was born and raised in the Dublin area. What you are hearing is his native accent. AT can do a decent RP accent if the script calls for it (Poldark, Desperate Romantics, in The Hobbit he used a variation of Richard Armitage's native accent).

BTW, the large number of Irish immigrants to the US has influenced certain geographical American Accents.

reply

What you are hearing is his native accent.


So this is what a Dublin accent sounds like? Because I do agree with the OP that it barely sounded Irish, or for that matter anywhere specific, to my ears. It sounded sort of like a mix of Irish, British and American accents - or perhaps just a very subtle accent compared to what we usually hear in Irish films. Don't misunderstand me; I'm not doubting your word at all, but his accent was definitely noticeable to me simply for not being noticeable. Or, rather, being barely different from that of the English characters despite Lombard's Irish nationality.

I've noticed something similar with Liam Cunningham, also a Dubliner, but I thought perhaps he was deliberately muting his accent for an international audience (because being Irish was not central to most of the characters I've seen him play). Is the Dublin accent very distinct from that of other parts of Ireland?

reply

I only heard the Irish break through occasionally. To me, Toby Stephens was the one trying to use an American accent.

reply

Lombard is an adventurer who travels the world trying to strike it rich. You could speculate that he had gone to the US, committed some crimes, and had to flee the country -- having acquired some American tinge to his accent in the process.

reply

As someone who was born in Ireland, I can confirm that is an Irish accent. There are loads of types of Irish accent (there are 3 or 4 different types just in Dublin!) and some Irish people just don't have very strong accents.

To be honest, I was actually happy to hear him talk with his own native accent, as often Irish actors are made to exaggerate their own accents and it usually sounds over the top... that's probably what a lot of you are used to hearing, which is why this might sound strange

reply

absolutely.

not all Irishmen and women have a diddly-dee accent!

reply