MovieChat Forums > One Big Happy (2015) Discussion > Another "immaculate conception" misconce...

Another "immaculate conception" misconception?


Just saw a preview for this and once again the media misstates what the immaculate conception is; it was the conception of Mary, not the conception of Jesus. She was conceived without original sin; it's not about conception without sex.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

I came here to see if anyone else realized that

reply

Okay, that is not true. I don't know where you heard this, but Mary was human and as much of a sinner as anyone. No man or woman is without sin, except Jesus, who took the form of man to be the perfect sacrifice. Jesus was conceived through the Holy Spirit. Show me the passage that refutes this. There is nothing biblical to support your claim.

Worshipping Mary is the same as worshipping an idol.

reply

Okay, that is not true. I don't know where you heard this, but Mary was human and as much of a sinner as anyone.


Of course she was human; that's the point - she was conceived without the taint of original sin; she was the only human conceived without original sin.

No man or woman is without sin


She was conceived without original sin.

Show me the passage that refutes this. There is nothing biblical to support your claim.


That's the point - it's not in the bible. It's dogma, not doctrine. When the bible was written (by men), science was at the point that people thought that a man basically planted a seed in a woman; as time went on, they understood that conception was part man and part woman, so it was deemed that Mary had to have been conceived without original sin.

http://catholicism.about.com/od/holydaysandholidays/p/Imm_Conception.h tm

Worshipping Mary is the same as worshipping an idol.


Who said anything about that?

reply