MovieChat Forums > Still Alice (2015) Discussion > Alec Baldwin's character

Alec Baldwin's character


Just saw this movie today on Netflix. I thought it was really good. The one part of the storyline that did not make any sense, was Alec Baldwin's character insisting on the move to Minnesota to work at the Mayo clinic. Considering what his wife was going through, they would be leaving close family at the most critical time. Just didn't make sense. On a separate note, it occurred to me when I was watching this, it's the second time in a movie that Hunter Parrish has played Alec Baldwin's son. He did it previously in the movie "It's Complicated".

reply

I interpreted it as him not being able to handle what was happening.

reply

I thought when watching the movie it was basically avoidance.

But I have since read the book and you get a sense of his opinions a bit more (even though it's from Alice's perspective). In particular, she overhears a conversation he has with the kids about the move (they are against it) and he basically says 1) it's a big chance for his work...basically heading towards improvements re cancer, potentially a big deal for the world in general and 2) "old' Alice i.e. pre-dementia would in other circumstances have been very much in favour of him pursuing this opportunity for his career and cancer treatment.

However, as the book is from Alice's perspective, you can tell even before her Alzheimer's symptoms get bad that she regrets her and John being so career-focussed and wishes to spend more time with him, so it's possible she would actually have secretly been upset about such a move even without Alzheimer's.

I also think John had basically already checked out as there was clearly no hope of stopping the disease progression and returning her to normal so he was essentially choosing this work to escape his mourning or had already gone through the mourning period and essentially saw Alice as past it such that he was focusing on other things.

reply