A Deleted Scene!


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3PsPdVyqG2U I loved it...

reply

Wow.... the look on Newt's face when he realizes that Queenie was right, about which school is better!

reply

no, hogwarts is still the best... it might not have a great song but otherwise it is the best.

reply

hogwarts 4 life

reply

Forgive me.... but I have never been a fan, of the caste system at Hogwarts. That each students' worth in society is based, on which House they were sorted into. It also does not help that during Dumbledore's tenure as Headmaster, Hogwarts could not keep a Defense Against the Dark Arts teacher for more than a year. How on earth, were the students supposed to pass that subject, on their O.W.L.s and N.E.W.T.s?

reply

you realise that Voldemort put a curse on that post because he was rejected by dumbledore... hence dumbledore was never able to keep one DADA teacher for more than one year. and there was not a caste system at Hogwarts they were all chose on based on their abilities, choices and mind set not because they were born in a certain class...

reply

you realise that Voldemort put a curse on that post because he was rejected by dumbledore...


My point still stands.... how were the students expected to pass that subject on their O.W.L.s and N.E.W.T.s?


and there was not a caste system at Hogwarts they were all chose on based on their abilities, choices and mind set


No one is sorted based on their abilities or choices. They are sorted based on a belief system that one personality trait, is superior than the others. It is why the rivalry between the Houses is so strong. Reflecting the rivalry between the four founders. The fact, that family members tend to be in a single House proves, it is a caste system.

reply


No one is sorted based on their abilities or choices. They are sorted based on a belief system that one personality trait, is superior to the others. It is why the rivalry between the Houses is so strong. Reflecting the rivalry between the four founders. The fact, that family members tend to be in a single House proves, it is a caste system.

you with due respect, know nothing about the caste system if you don't live in India... where people used to and still in some areas are put up with the stuff their caste has been doing since generations... here you are chosen in a certain house if you got traits of it and that's a good thing since there he or she would be more accepted... in caste system you are not allowed to follow the path you chose while here you could chose any work you desire and not just that, you could even chose a house of your own liking as Harry did...

reply

they were all chose on based on their abilities, choices and mind set not because they were born in a certain class..


Hmmm not really. They were choisen because of their character, something they were born with and could not choose. This whole system is ridiculous.

reply

Lovely scene. From the very raw looking CG, I gather this was cut early on. Makes you wonder why the "I wanna be a wizard" line was still included in trailers.

reply

It's just a catchy phrase. Good trailer material.

reply

Yes, I get that. It just seems dishonest to advertise scenes that you know for a fact won't make the final cut.

reply

It most certainly is, but as you know it's a cynical business. They only want to sell tickets.

reply

It most certainly is, but as you know it's a cynical business. They only want to sell tickets.


Too true.... but I actually understand why this scene was cut. As cute was it is, it is rather random. It is also completely incompatible with the next scene, which features Graves punching Credence in the face.

reply

Absolutely. That would probably feel just as tonally strange as the moment Yates and co decided to go from the dark scene of Mary Lou's death to the more light-hearted scene of catching beasts.

reply

[deleted]

Thanks for that.

________
http://youtu.be/GAIJ3Rh5Qxs

reply

no problem

reply