All easy suggestions to come up with when you're not potentially going to die every 2 minutes. Especially in a room full of this many people all arguing with each other.
- How about throwing a bunch of clothes on the "eye" so it can't see?
May work. But I'm pretty sure that was an energy weapon, not a camera.
- How about constructing a rope out of clothes, belts, etc. and throwing it over the light fixture above and climb out?
Wouldn't work. As soon as their feet left the pads they would be zapped.
- How about grabbing one of the dead bodies when it falls on you, on your circle, then use it as a shield and walk out of there as the eye blasts the dead body?
They can't touch each other. Go watch the opening scene again. And even if they did, if this is a weapon that uses electricity, holding a dead body in front of you won't help.
-How about seeing if you can switch circles? Stepping on the floor set the alarm off, not necessarily lifting feet so they might have been able to jump around/ dodge blast.
We know for a fact that they can't. Stepping off YOUR CIRCLE results in you being blasted. And what would this accomplish anyway? How do you dodge a bolt of energy?
- How about constructing a ground so that the electrical blast is shunted and doesn't kill anyone?
From what? What are they going to "construct a ground" out of? And how does this work with your previous suggestion that the bolts are not electrical and thus couldn't be shunted. Otherwise the dead body would simply conduct the current into your body and kill you anyway.
They all stopped trying anything at all in the first five minutes. They had rings, watches, etc. Throw them into the dark, break something Try ANYTHING.
Maybe you missed it, but they were under a time crunch and under extreme stress. They stopped trying things because they got bogged down in arguments about who should die next. But there's no indication that it would have been possible for them to escape. All the things you suggest could equally be a waste of time to what they ended up doing in the movie.
Seen the "Bunch of people in a room only one may live" movie plot about a dozen times now. I keep watching them like tugging on a bad tooth. I keep hoping there is going to be some actual human insight.
Except based on your argument, you don't seem to want the characters to act human. You want them to be smart and make the right choice all the time, but people are NOT like that. In high stress situations, most people break down. You don't get a persons best when they're afraid they're going to die every 2 minutes.
What was up with people just standing there while alien ships hovered over, like got nothing better to do than creepily stand utterly motionless and dead silent on some random backstreet? That just introduced more annoying questions than it answered.
I'm sorry. Maybe you've seen so many alien crafts that you would just go about your day if you saw one, but I'm willing to bet most people would stop and stare. What do YOU have to do with your day that's more important than *beep* aliens, dude?
And what questions did that introduce that we didn't already have?
- If the people he encountered at the end seemed to have been survivors like him, that would have been interesting, what kinds of people would they be, would they have a knowing look, a guilty look? Could he be the only non-child/pregnant woman? That would have been funny.
They pretty clearly were at least mostly survivors. The implication being that the entire world is subject to this experiment. Which means that in the end, the world will end up with about 1\49th the population if every group is made up of 50 people and only one person survives. So the world would go from about 7 billion people, to about 143 million.
- If the people he encountered at the end knew he was a survivor, perhaps the media was there and they immediately start asking him how he got out, that others had come out too. That could have been interesting.
What media? Again, everybody has been taken. There would be no media to report or interview anyone, unless we assume some members of the media had "won" their game and immediately went out and started finding other "winners" to interview.
Not to mention that would be the start of a whole different movie, not an end to this one.
The new home of Welcome to Planet Bob:
http://kingofbob.blogspot.ca/
reply
share