Moments of Shock - Most Evil Villain
I gotta admit, the Whorseson Jr. bit was a shocker. Pure evil. And, to find women nailed to the walls and bath tub and hung from the ceiling or on the bed with their throat cut all the while Jr. is just going about like its nothing.
In my opinion, he was the most evil person/creature/monster in the entire game and this element of the game really took me by surprise. It was brutal.