MovieChat Forums > Big Brother Canada (2013) Discussion > Peter & Sarah: who should replace them?

Peter & Sarah: who should replace them?

posted 9 years ago by a_l_i_e_n
13 replies | jump to latest

Peter said "Tim should win and will win, and will become the greatest player in Big Brother history".Sarah said she wanted Kelsey to "cut Tim, take the brothers and take it all home", meaning she believed that in the end Kelsey would win against the brothers.

Maybe it's time for the "Big Brother Canada Side Show" producers to find some new experts. Now, even though I didn't like her, I have to say I think Cassandra would make a very astute judge of gameplay. I think Dallas would be interesting, too, and they'd certainly both be entertaining.

[–] SheWorksHardForTheMoney 9 years ago

Totally agree, especially since most of the eliminated house guests predicted the brothers to win.

[–] kristen1165 9 years ago

Sarah only picked Kelsey because she's the only female.

[–] trentlivesinanigloo 9 years ago

don't forget they mentioned about jury members voting based on their emotions. i'd say i agree Tim played a better game and Kelsey played better than the brothers but because the Jury is a bunch of bitter people they voted against her and gave the money to the brothers. they will never admit this fault because they obviously have some high egos when they shouldn't.

[–] kristen1165 9 years ago

I very much disagree with you that Kelsey should have won over the brothers. I think jurors like Mitch and Joel voted game, not personal. So just because it's your opinion that Kelsey should have won, it doesn't mean that the jurors not voting for her meant they voted bitterly, that was just their opinion. Don't forget those juror segments are often edited to be misleading. I remember in BB16 it looked like the jury didn't recognize Derrick's game, but that turned out not to be the case at all.

[–] The-Demon 9 years ago

Well Sarah is probably one of the worst winners. She had zero strategy and every player she was banking on was evicted the following week which shows she really knows nothing about the game. She was even proud of the fact she lost both comps in the final HOH and was tken to final 2 and won. And the only reason she won is because Godfrey played a flawless gsme where he pulled all the strings and nobody saw it. That's how I looked at Godfrey. Not everyone has to agree just my opinion.

Peter doesn't know how to play BB. It's obvious based on how horrible his game was. But I don't look at Peter as a BB expert. I look at him as an entertainer. He's got great charisma and not everyone who was a reality tv personality can have great skills to be on camera and memorize lines that he also writes himself.

Now I think the problem really is that there is a difference between predicting and liking a player. Peter loves Tim. Great but that's not the reason he'll win. It's like Bruno for example saying he's gonna pick The Brothers because they're from Ottawa like him. That Wouk be a stupid reason to predict that. He actually liked and predicted Ramsey. He Amy like the Brothers because they're from Ottawa and wants them to win but he didn't predict them.

[–] Red_Identity 9 years ago

Sarah had zero strategy? I would say that the fact that she won proves she had one determining crucial aspect of her game that Godfrey missed- social game...

"You also believe that boyhood was well written so im not sure i can put much stock in your beliefs"

[–] The-Demon 9 years ago

Ok explain what her strategy was.

Girl did everything wrong. If u wanna say her strategy was to make fans feel sorry for her and she benefited from twists I'll give you that. But she voted out Willow, she voted for Britnee when voted were revealed she just got lucky.

And btw a lot of payers I'm critical of I've met in person and they're sweet people. Neda, Peter, Sarah and others. Immjust talking about their gameplay.

[–] northwellguyII 9 years ago

Sarah's "strategy" was to allow BB producers to let her advance. It was so obvious that things were manipulated in her favor because of the fact she was such a bad player they had to go way beyond normal corruption to help her advance. And she still almost screwed it up by failing miserably in the last HoH comp.

"Oh behold.. ye who do not respect your enemy", Sun Tzu

[–] The-Demon 9 years ago

See I don't think too far that they corrupted the gsme in her favor. I think the twists were all planned in advance and she was coincidentally benefiting from it. Even Canada voting for her and Britnee being HN so they can win the secret power (that she sucked at) was only to see her reaction. It was great TV to see someone who cried a lot think Canada hated her and made her HN.

Now what I think production should have done was punish her for constantly breaking rules. The 2 I remember was drinking alcohol when she was a HN and when she talked to Godfrey during the Triple Eviction voting. Arissa always says that before they vote.

[–] dancinlukey 9 years ago

I think Peter is great! He is the best thing about the sideshow, he got a prediction wrong doesn't mean he shouldn't be on the show next year. If Big Brother was that easily predictable it would be a boring show!

[–] northwellguyII 9 years ago

Peter is an annoying douche.

Doesn't mean he can't do the show, though.

"Oh behold.. ye who do not respect your enemy", Sun Tzu

[–] Nizhsto 9 years ago

I just hope they don't bring Gary back. He stopped being funny a long time ago.

[–] northwellguyII 9 years ago

True

His whole schtick has worn old

"Oh behold.. ye who do not respect your enemy", Sun Tzu