please forget the rating, talk about the movie!
not every body likes this kind of cinema its a fact, and of-course people will rank a movie so high which is too good among other movies in the country(Turkey).
anyway! if you've seen any of Ceylan's works and if you get deep in characters and cinematography (and plus a good subtitle) you'll see that this is a great movie.
and please don't compare winter sleep with Indian Bollywood movies!!! (sigh)