MovieChat Forums > Everest (2015) Discussion > Damn Beck. You Were Huffin And Puffin Go...

Damn Beck. You Were Huffin And Puffin Going Up Them Stairs.


Am I the only one who said, "You might want to turnaround and head back to the plane?" I mean, how could he realistically think he was going to make it up Everest in bad weather, when he could barely make it up some stairs at a much lower altitude and in good weather?

reply

Maybe some of us bring too much background knowledge to the film. I already knew that Beck was an extremely fit guy who had summited six of the Seven Summits already and had been into climbing and extreme training for more than a decade. Even Sandy Pittman had a lot of mountaineering experience.

However, long airplane trips can be hard on the respiratory system and can give people coughs and minor dehydration so that could be a possible explanation of why he appeared to be winded. He would have had a 13-14 hour flight to someplace like Seoul or Shanghai then another flight of 6+ hours to Kathmandu. I didn't notice it.

reply

Look up "acclimatizing" (Beck even mentions it while huffing up the steps). There is a reason they had to spend 5-6 weeks in the environment getting ready to make the summit attempt.

reply

Now I see.

reply

I appreciate what you were saying about Beck when he was trekking, but remember the camp doctor gave him an "excellent" for his physical at Base Camp.🐭

reply

This brings up something that raised a question in my mind,namely the alcohol consumption, partying that was going on in the base camp.Doesn't that seem counter productive when trying to acclimatize oneself and when contrasted to the potential health risks associated with the altitudes highlighted in the film ?

This is why I had a problem with Jake Gyllenhaal's performance. He came across as a cocky, arrogant, reckless party animal, hardly the type of guide one would entrust with his life during such an endeavor.

reply


This is why I had a problem with Jake Gyllenhaal's performance. He came across as a cocky, arrogant, reckless party animal, hardly the type of guide one would entrust with his life during such an endeavor.


Not only did Gyllenhaal look nothing like Scott Fischer, his character in this film did not resemble Scott Fischer either. According to members of Scott's team, there was no drinking going on at base camp - they were much too serious about getting fit to climb, building up their red blood cell count, etc. They ate well (considering), but booze was not part of the equation.

Scott's widow was also disgusted at how he was portrayed. Scott Fischer was not some hippie party boy, he was a serious mountaineer who was highly regarded by fellow climbers. He was affable and charming, but nothing like the careless anything-goes persona assigned to him in the movie. Partial proof lies in the fact that his climbers may (based on results) have better prepared than Rob Hall's team in several respects, as they all reached the summit and got back down safely, with help from Boukreev during the storm, and all carried dexamethasone as an an antidote to the onset of HACE.

This article mentions Price-Fischer's disdain for the film:

http://www.news.com.au/entertainment/movies/new-movies/the-widow-of-scott-fischer-has-added-her-voice-to-the-chorus-condemning-the-new-everest-movie/news-story/8d3b5d0661c779b346c1211a828b6f13

It wasn't sour grapes. She refused a very lucrative offer to be involved with the film in some way (as a character IIRC).

reply

I read this link earlier on here and appreciated it as confirmation to my common sense and intuition. Hollywood can be so despicable at times with how it twists the truth !

reply