MovieChat Forums > The 100 (2014) Discussion > This show's science is terrible. Basical...

This show's science is terrible. Basically magic *spoilers*


Their gravity simulation explanation makes sense in regard to centripetal force early in the show. Thrusters are used to maintain the rotation of the ark and the centripetal force required for artificial gravity-like forces on the occupants. We see the entire construct of stations rotating along a central axis. This means their sensation of gravity would be away from the central axis down, inward up. As you climbed toward the center eventually there would be an increasing sensation of weightlessness and in the center axis standard microgravity.

It works on the same idea as swinging a pail of water- the water can remain in the bucket despite gravity pulling it down because of centripetal force.

This is an important thing to note because it means every time we see someone standing, their feet are aimed at the outermost point of the station in regards to the axis.

So what the hell is going on after most of the ark stations go to planetfall and Jaha is left up there? We know he is left with a ring-shaped system of modules that are damaged. We know he has gravity while he is on the station- everywhere, so his ring station must be rotating. An object in motion will tend to stay in motion unless another force acts upon it. So it would continue rotating until maybe earth's gravity began to have a significant effect- for an orbital object that could be decades or centuries or more.

So his station is rotating. He finds imaginary son-baby. He finds a spacesuit. he is too stupid to realize that duct tape or really any tape is a great short term measure for a crack on even pressurized glass so does not try that for THE ONLY PRESSURE SUIT LEFT ON THE STATION (which is weird all by itself, there should be many in every station.) Decides to try to do a no-tether, no propulsion EVA that amounts to jumping in the general direction.

Here's where things get weird. We don't see the station ring rotating in relation to earth or stars or anything at this point and even for a giant object like that, it has to rotate pretty fast to generate 1G of force, visibly noticeably at least. It should be. For him to be standing in the airlock like that, we should see that.

So he decides to take a leap. Now you have to consider that even were it rotating, because of the direction he perceives as down because of the centripetal force, it would have to be rotating in the OPPOSITE direction. This is actually a different direction than it would have been rotating when it was attatched to that central axis when it was the full Ark. In the earlier case it would be along what we think of the common rotation axis of a ring. To make it like the way it shows gravity as he looks out of the lock, it would have to be along a z-axis rotation. So not only is it rotating, it's rotating in a way that he is now shooting at a target going continually downward from him, not right in front of him. Once again, we don't see this.

So he leaps, unaided, manages to thread a 2 meter needle over what, 500 meters maybe? and then deftly hits the airlock door as he floats in. He immediately hits the floor as the lock pressurizes. Legit LOL here. The presence of air is not what creates the sensation of gravity here or anywhere.

reply

Yeah Jaha coming down to Earth isn't even worth analyzing like this imo because it's so far fetched. They wanted to keep one of their big name actors alive on the show so the writers took a lot of leeway for that to happen. This was probably the moment where I was the most annoyed with the science but it doesn't bother me so much anymore because I've accepted that it's science fiction.

reply

I was gonna bring that one up in the second installment. A missile that was designed without landing in mind, no protocols for it, no reverse thrusters to slow descent, no parachuse, literally designed to explose a little bit above it's ground target, and he just sort of skipped it into a desert? That thing would be in a million pieces and he would be a husk of barely-identifiable scattered carbon.

I agree, it's science fiction, and this being CW, it's obviously teen-oriented scifi focusing more on the drama and action than science... but wow still.

What a lovely way to burn...

reply

Yeah the science on the show is really sketchy sometimes. I think it got a little better in S3, although the Jaha situation may have just been my limit and now I just don't care about the science at all anymore lol

reply

I usually try to just suspend disbelief at the terrible science but Jaha riding down to Earth on a nuclear missile was a step too far even for me! Still I'm old enough to remember the original Star Trek where every week Captain Kirk and various unnamed crew members who you knew were just cannon fodder, used to beam down to an alien planet that miraculously had perfectly breathable air and the same gravity as Earth. I suppose we have to accept that it would be very difficult to make sci-fi shows if they had to get all the science exactly right.

reply

Science fiction can work without making your audience grown and roll their eyes. But just like one of the cast of a Star Trek series said about how many scripts can you write before it starts to get stupid? But from the start this show took so many liberties with the stories it was a target for growning and eye rolling.

reply

[deleted]

*yawn

reply

The noise someone made before they realized they were waking up to more sad part time unskilled labor.

reply

Metal engineer

reply

>>sets up sound equipment for a band on weekends

What a lovely way to burn...

reply

[deleted]

The trouble with analyzing equipment from a science fiction show is that you can't really examine any of it.


Jaha threading the needle might've been from his using the ship's computer, or his technical know-how, to analyze and create a controlled burst to do so.

The "missile" isn't a missile as we know it. That's a sci fi missile. For all we know it can transform into optimus prime. It's not far fetched to say that it may be able to land instead of detonate using what are advanced-impossibly-good-thrusters. I will admit, the most suspect part of it is him sealing himself inside the missile and surviving in that tiny pod, but again, he's using sci-fi materials.

That entire missile is made of phlebotonium, we don't know how it works.

Same with with the blood transfusions in the last two seasons - all of them include sci fi that is impossible, but may be possible with tech 300-400 years from now that to laymen would seem like wizardry because they're so incomprehensible to understand.

Hell, we don't even know much about the education of these people. Some of them may have some of the best technical skills of anyone we've ever met just because "future teaching methods". They might have all been on mind-enhancing drugs which make them who they are.

It's a real crapshoot to analyze. I will admit this though - they've added enough mumbo jumbo to create plausible deniability, there's waaaay too many factors involving a race of people who literally do nothing but fly in space all day to.... figure out how to better fly in space when they need to.

reply

This show is for teen girls and tween women, what exactly did you expect?

reply

That's why is called science FICTION

reply

“Groan”? Fucking really? Have you groan up yet?

reply

R_Kane (15219) 30 minutes ago
“Groan”? Fucking really? Have you groan up yet?


Who did you quote, my dear?
Or was the post to what you replied after 7 months changed within 30 mins? 🤔​

reply