Good but story better suited for TV Episode.
It just seemed to lack the right conflict or "World Teetering on Destruction" sense of urgency that usually accompanied the feature films. The story centered on a "Mcguffin" that Idris Elba's character wanted for some sort of weapon ...I think. Also despite the fact I didn't recognize Idris in his makeup that ISN'T a curve ball compliment to the makeup dept. either..as even the "villains" prosthetic masks looked cheap and left over from episodes of Deep Space 9. Why JJ didn't take a que from his "other franchise" and have the visual effects dept make some of the Aliens "less human" is beyond me as Aliens walkin in background seemed overtly Humanoid. I mean the budget was $185 million and honestly I don't see where it was spent. $185 million is a GARGANTUAN amount of $$ and they couldn't have the Aliens look more...I dunno "Alien?" Sorry to grumble on but to me even the dialogue frequently didn't "work" and seemed preachy. Their female Alien friend uses English phrases like: " if you choose to do this your on your own" but doesn't know what a "welcome mat" is? OK...Maybe I'm being a lil too picky as she did like Public Enemy. Overall script seemed rushed...Love the cast and ...Oh..That's another thing..The fact Anton Yelchin (Chekov) had passed away tragically prior to the films release unfortunately layered a melancholy blanket everytime he was on screen. Such a shame. Overall a 4 outta 10. ..And what was with Sulu being gay? Not that there's anything wrong with that mind you...but it just seemed to come out of nowhere with zero mention in the previous films. I heard even George Takei was less than pleased with that character decision. Anyway I hope ST4 happens just with a better story and NOT nessecarily more CGI; one of the most beloved films in the franchise was Part 4 The Voyage Home, taking place in modern day San Francisco and imho the BEST of ALL the films. We shall see. Fingers crossed.
share