MovieChat Forums > Whiplash (2014) Discussion > Was he rushing or was he dragging?

Was he rushing or was he dragging?


Was he rushing or was he dragging?

reply

Well, if it really still matters... he was rushing almost constantly during that scene. But essentially, he was just messing up horribly, varying in tempo, not just rushing. Nobody at a music conservatory, not even a mediocre drummer, would have played this badly. It's a movie, the main actor (who probably played the kit himself in this scene) is capable but no genius. He essentially just tried to "mess up" somehow audibly.

reply

It's interesting to know that he really was messing up. I'm not a drummer and like a lot of people, it all sounded the same to me and it sounded good. I wondered if Fletcher was just being a dick. I mean, he was being a dick even if the student was screwing up, but I mean, I wondered if he was just creul enough that he'd act that way even if students were good.

reply

Both.
Possibly neither.

--

"If I wasn't paying attention, that's a plot-hole"
"If I didn't like it, that's a plot-hole"

reply

This post is not my tempo.

reply

Sounded all the same to my untrained ears *shrugs*

reply