Does anyone else notice Katie is definitely the rich one of the group?
You never see where she lives, she's always wearing nice clothes/has nice accessories, and she's always afraid to do things like she's a girly-girl (example: the bull, the rock on the camping trip)
I'd say she is definitely the second-most attractive girl though, right behind Shae. But Katie seems like the classiest one of the bunch, so it might be a toss-up. I used to think Cara was hot, but after the whole ex-girlfriend thing and finding pictures of her naked online (not complaining, just saying) it's hard not to look at her as the trashiest girl (tied with Ashley, of course).
All in all, as a 22 year old male, I must say this show is my guilty pleasure. I would give anything to meet Shaine and the boys and go out and cause mayhem in the West Virginia countryside.
Wish this show didn't have such a low rating, you just gotta take it for what it is: a somewhat scripted show featuring a bunch of country kids having fun.