MovieChat Forums > Girl Meets World (2014) Discussion > Do you think the life lessons were too h...

Do you think the life lessons were too heavy-handed?


In my opinion, GMW's biggest flaw was the way life lessons were handled in most episodes. Too often, it felt like the writers tried too hard to drive home a point or moral, rather than letting the storyline flow naturally. This was often done with characters repeating the same line throughout an episode to the extent that the dialogue felt unnatural. One exception I can recall is "The Forgiveness Project." That episode, I didn't feel like the theme of forgiveness was excessively driven in. However, with some of the same writers from BMW also working on GMW, I expected better writing for the series overall.

I know the show wasn't meant to be a carbon copy of BMW, but with that show, the life lessons felt more organic to the story and even if a moral was "revealed" at the end of an episode, it didn't feel like the writers were beating the audience over the head with it. It's like the "show, don't tell" rule of writing. Girl Meets World told the moral of the story (repeatedly), while Boy Meets World showed it.

That said, I enjoyed GMW but wish it could've had more time (or another network) to allow the show to further develop, and I wish the writing hadn't talked down to the audience so much.

---------------
This world is but a canvas to our imagination.
-Henry David Thoreau

reply

Heavy-Handed is putting it lightly. The writers made other Disney shows seem clever and subtle in comparison.

reply

That has always been my main issue. The feeling of forced morality. I loved the lessons but at times they seemed heavy handed. Plus I had a problem with Cory and his delivery. Other then that I loved the show. For me it was the charm and talent of the 2 starlets. I loved the interaction between Riley and Maya.

reply

The show was too preachy, not funny. The overall morals of every episode could be summarized in a few words: Riley + Maya's friendship for life. Yawn.

reply

I think Ben Savage's delivery had more to do with the writing. The writers gave Cory and Topanga completely different personalities than they had in BMW. Cory was basically an adult goofball when he wasn't teaching, and Topanga was only a typical "mom" character except when she saved the cafe from closing.

As for the lessons, it's a shame the writers didn't trust the audience enough to let them put the pieces together and figure out the morals on their own. Some of the time spent driving the lessons in could have been used to develop other areas of the story and characters.

---------------
This world is but a canvas to our imagination.
-Henry David Thoreau

reply

No kidding they were heavy-handed it felt less like a sitcom and more like The More You Know🌟

reply