MovieChat Forums > Star Wars: Episode VIII - The Last Jedi (2017) Discussion > Those bombers, those stupid effing bombe...

Those bombers, those stupid effing bombers


They have got to be the stupidest plot device in any sci-fantasy movie ever, and their ineffectiveness is matched by the incompetency of the pilots involved. They are easy targets for the First Order to pick off, and they fly in such close formation that chain reactions occur. Perhaps their bombs are extremely powerful, but that's more reason to keep them apart, and what's more, where are the fighter escorts for them? And where are their shields? If the main Resistance cruiser can have powerful shields, why can't they? And don't get me started on the unnecessarily complicated way of launching the bombs by electromagnetic propulsion.

I think it would've been better if they were missile launchers, firing off thousands of them and becoming armed shortly before hitting the target, and what's more, have them leave trails, too. Those scenes in Battlestar Galactica were so cool, they should've done it here. Minimal risk to the ships and pilots, and the target will still blow up.

No, the ultimate aim of those ships were as a plot device to introduce us to Rose and her sister. It's such a shame we never got to know the more capable sister, you know, the one who actually saved the Resistance and heroically gave her life, and not Rose, who wasted valuable time and ultimately threatened the Resistance by preventing Finn from heroically giving HIS life for the cause. Then again, I have to wonder what would Rose's sister have done if that control pad had never fallen down?

reply

Thing that makes it even worse is that decades before there were buzz droids. Instead of wasting cash on huge, slow sitting duck bombers, combine buzz droids with bombs, and save bombers lives and the rebellion (resistance. Potayto, potahto) money.

As far as I remember buzz droids were launched and explode out of a missile then attach to ships.

Sure something would have to fire the missile but it wouldn't have to wait till it's literally above the target like it's WW2.

reply

To be frank, I think Battlestar Galactica (the new one, mind) is FAR COOLER than ANYTHING Star Wars EVER did.

reply