MovieChat Forums > V/H/S/2 (2013) Discussion > The Aliens Should Have Saved the Dog

The Aliens Should Have Saved the Dog


For one thing, you don't kill the dog. I know it's not real, but it's just kind of an unwritten rule!

It would have been so cool if the alien walked up to the dog at the end AFTER it died. You see a flash of light. Then the dog gets up and runs away. The dog can never tell anyone what happened anyway!

reply

*beep* the dog. Unwritten rule is to always kill the dog as they do in movies!

reply

Old Yeller would like a word with you.

reply

Dog was killed in I Am Legend..... they made it this huge awesome important scene too!

I don't like the animals and pets getting killed horribly in movies either though. I agree with you

reply

I agree. I didn't like that Tank the dog died. I suppose it was the image of him that touched a nerve in me.

reply

I think that a stronger ending would have been the dog running away, a flash of the dog running in the daytime in a deserted area, and then a final flash of someone finding the dog and picking it up (thus finding the footage), the implication being that the aliens came, snatched/killed the children, and then vanished without the rest of the world even noticing. Thus they could presumably do the same again.
Now THAT would have been creepier.

reply

Dogs always die in horror movies, save for a few. It makes me sad and puzzled, but then again maybe dogs get killed because they can sense the evil.

The Dude Abides

reply

no cares about a stupid dog

reply

False. No one care about heartless neckbeards.

reply

LOL, i'm clean shaven and why would I care about a stupid dog in a crappy movie? You probably have a "neck beard"

reply

Best Dog death ever in a horror movie, John Carpenters "The THING." Multiple dog deaths at once, ha... And Gruesome too..

reply

Wow.............what a comeback.

I'm A 32 Year Old I.T. Man Who Works In The Basement, Yes I Do The Whole Lonely Hearts Thing.

reply

i'd be crying for the dog's death but i'd be cheering yours!

reply

I hated that they killed the dog.

I kept saying "No not the doggie. Not the doggie! Take the foul white trash family, but NOT the dog!"

And the way the film kept hurting the dog yet saving it...then kills it ANYWAY!





I'd say this cloud is Cumulo Nimbus.
Didn't he discover America?
Penfold, shush.

reply