The sound of the gunshot got there before the bullet did?

I think I'm with you on that one. When we see the guy coming out of the woods, as if we have the POV of Dwight, he does seem pretty close. so yeah, i think the time is off. I looked it up, and sound travels at 330 meters (~1000 feet) per second. That seems farther than where we saw the guy come out of the tree line.

Yes, sound travels at a little over 1,000 FPS, but a 1 second delay between the bullet's and sound's arrival isn't as simple as that. At ~1,000 feet (~333 yards), the time of flight of the bullet is about a half second, and the sound takes a second to get there, so there would only be about a half second delay.

In fact, now that I think about it some more, a roughly half second delay is the most you'll ever have with the rifle he was using. By the time you get out to say, 1,000 yards, the sound has pretty much caught up with the bullet, because by that time, the bullet has slowed from its initial muzzle velocity of ~2,600 FPS to ~650 FPS, and the speed of sound remains constant here (at 1,000 yards both the bullet and sound will arrive in ~3 seconds).

I am not going to rewatch to count seconds. There are too many more movies to watch... And i don't know much about headshots, I have never taken one. Not yet...

Well, ~350 to ~500 yards away would result in the biggest delay possible with the rifle he was using (about a half second delay), and a human head appears very small to the naked eye when that far away. This is why scopes (telescopic sights) are normally used for accurate long range shooting.

But I will say this. Very cool scene, very effective with the timing of it all, in general, where we (and the dude who got shot), are like, "what the F was that", and then it gets a little clearer to us what is going on ("oh it's a gun shot..."), and then the next thing we see is a lost jaw bone.

It was effective movie making, no matter how fast sound travels in a sec. I hope the director makes more.

It was a good scene, but its unbelievability/contradictions take away from it. It wouldn't have taken much to make the scene believable. Just give him a scoped rifle chambered for something fast, like a .22-250 or .220 Swift (typical long-range varmint cartridges; rifles so-chambered usually have high-powered scopes and heavy barrels, and are very common), and then you'd have your ~1 second delay at ~500 yards, the shot would be believable because the rifle and scope are already set up for such shots at that range on human head-sized or smaller targets (e.g., ground hogs), and after he fired the shots, have him drive to the scene in his truck, or on a 4-wheeler, or whatever, so that the right amount of distance is indicated.

As it stands, he walked to the scene in 15 to 20 seconds, and with an average human walking speed of ~3 MPH (4.4 FPS), that only places him ~25 yards away. Not only is that way too close to have a perceptible delay between the bullet's and the sound's arrival, but it also makes him look incompetent, i.e., missing the first shot with a rifle at only ~25 yards.

I don't dance, tell jokes or wear my pants too tight, but I do know about a thousand songs.

reply share

add reply

formatting help

Here's another Monday morning backseat driver chiming in! To me the scene should have gone thusly:

Teddy aims down at Dwight. He talks about shooting him in the gut and is cut off mid-sentence as his jaw disappears. Dwight lies stunned, Ben emerges from the woods calling out....

reply share

add reply

formatting help