Filmed in the USA?


Thought it was supposed to be Iranian?

reply

Not Iranian – even though they've used the 'Iranian Vampire Western' tagline. It's an American indie shot in California, made in Farsi by an Iranian-American director. That clear it up?

reply

No matter where it was made, I hope this'll encourage Iranians to make movies and encourage some movement to the world community. Iran used to be quite metropolitan but got to be such a closed society. I hope the pendulum is swinging the other way.

reply

'No matter where it was made, I hope this'll encourage Iranians to make movies and encourage some movement to the world community. Iran used to be quite metropolitan but got to be such a closed society. I hope the pendulum is swinging the other way.'

Iran has been making notable film for years. How can you make the above statement when their films are being critically acclaimed around the world for years.

It's that man again!!

reply

The Iranian New Wave started in the 60s, and is technically still going. Some of the worlds most respected directors are Iranian, most notably Abbas Kiarostami and Mohsen Makhmalbaf. Of the younger generation Jafar Panahi and Asghar Farhadi are getting a lot of attention. Remember when A Separation won best foreign film at the Oscars?

My 1000 favorite films - http://www.imdb.com/list/PkAV7BgvMJg

reply

Iran may have its problems but quite a few notable films have come out of Iran in the past years.

reply

I think the ratio of great Iranian films to Iranians, which is to say per capita great film production, is pretty much the best in the world, these days.

And Iranian food ("Persian" in the U.S., of course, or else no one would patronize it) is amazing.

It's silly to think you have a sense of a nation's culture from just their movies and their cuisine, but I can't help thinking that we blew it politically, big-time, there, and that there's some parallel world where they're our biggest Middle East ally and the greatest liberalizing force among Islamic nations.

Prepare your minds for a new scale of physical, scientific values, gentlemen.

reply

And You forgot the most beautiful actresses.

reply

Yeah they make great films, have beautiful women and great food! Not a bad trifecta.

reply

It's because they don't have Rothschild-run banks. That's pretty much it.

reply

The marketing of the film was misleading, maybe even dishonest. Was there anything apart from shoddy Persian and the occasional Hijab that would connect this film with Iran? Were there any spots of uniquely Iranian culture, architecture, religion, ect.? I have nothing against Iran as the setting, but as far as I can tell it served no purpose in the story and existed only to imply that this was a foreign import rather than a domestic production.

reply

Yes I agree. I was under the assumption it was made over there as well

reply

Arguably this wasn't even a Persian language film. The real language of the film is the subtitles--which one, regardless of native language, must read to follow the plot. The spoken Persian is a rough, awkward, translation of the English subtitles (The Director's primary language). IMO, Faux-Iranian is a better description.

I actually liked the film. But this whole Iranian/Persian thing gets more ridiculous the more you think about it. If a French language film were done like this people would wonder if it was intended as a joke.

reply

Agreed. The whole "Iranian film" marketing is such a sham, it makes me like the movie less. It's like she wanted to get the attention that westernized foreign (especially middle eastern) films get in the American market to steam line this somehow

reply

You do realise that films set in a certain location are not always filmed there. For example, The Great Gatsby is set in USA but was filmed in Australia. What may even surprise you more, is that the Lord of the Rings and Hobbit series were not actually filmed in Middle-Earth, nor were the Chronicles of Narnia filmed in Narnia.

SpiltPersonality

reply

hahahaha.

reply

The question isn't 'Why was it filmed in the US?' but 'Why was it set in Iran?'. Why not film it in English if that's the language the actors speak? It makes your movie much easier to market. This movie got a lot of hype because it was marketed as being an Iranian movie, but it's not. Pretentious, arthouse douchebags love foreign movies just because they're foreign but this movie was made in California by mostly Americans. It's pretty shady, really. There was no reason to set it in Iran. It didn't take use the location at all. It didn't matter where it was set. The language could've easily been English. It didn't make any difference. They just pretended like it's an Iranian movie to get the arthouse crowd excited because they're the only ones that'll like this long, drawn out, boring movie.

reply

The question isn't 'Why was it filmed in the US?' but 'Why was it set in Iran?'.


That's a pretty stupid question then. The story took place in Iran, hence it was set in Iran.

It didn't matter where it was set.


Clearly it does to you.

reply

The story took place in Iran only to make it seem more exotic and to make use of the hijab as some image to connect to vampirism.
Why was it actually set in Iran? Language wasn't an issue--this entire cast primarily speaks English.
You can't really say the story takes place in Iran when the story uses nothing Iranian to substantiate itself.

reply

Let's get real. Does anyone really expect that this movie would get approval to be filmed in Iran by its government censors? Sure, there has been criticism of the Farsi speaking skills in this movie (in this discussion thread) and in the 2011 movie Circumstance. Both were directed by Iranian-Americans, made outside of Iran and the actors were not native speakers (and unlikely to ever visit Iran again). But until things change in Iran, this is the reality of making a film that is unpopular with Iran's leaders. It seems silly to me to keep bringing this up when Iranian-American film makers make films about Iran.

reply

I think you are way overstating the censorship in Iran. Yes there is a censor but an admitted censor is someone you can negotiate with. Try negotiating with the MPAA they will not even tell you what part of your film is risking getting you a NC17 which in hyper commercial USA is commercial death. There is all kinds of censorship in this world. Hollywood is one of the most censored and gutless and intolerant film factories on the planet. What makes the intellectual cowardice in American films and the constant glorification of American imperialism and its crimes by Hollywood productions is that it is voluntary Hollywood chooses to collaborate with Washington. If you live in a country where there is very strict rules like Iran it is not the filmmakers chose and they can only appeal to the people in the Ministry on a human level and hope for the best. In contrast no one put a gun to the head of the producers of films like BLACK HAWK DOWN to have the screenplay subjected to multiple draft review and changes at the hands of the Pentagon screenplay department. In Iran it may not be possible to make films with female junkies and vampires but then again Iran does not put out sick fascist crap like AMERICAN SNIPER.

reply

[deleted]