So was the wife beating thing...
Something Ethan just made up to justify victimizing Grainy? I do believe he was nasty enough to poison a dog.
Let's face it, he was a nasty SOB. I can see kids wanting to f@ck with him. The totally illogical thing was the kid picking up the bell. It was very obviously a bell, so, duh, it would make a noise.
As for the suicide, how would anyone know it could trigger a suicide? I think their sentence was appropriate.
What do you got on? Loafers? You don't slaughter animals in loafers!