What exactly happene to Meryl Streep in the ending? She casts a spell in herself and gets swallowed up? She just gives up on life after being so intent on delivering the boy to the giant? It didnt make much sense....
Just like in the play, it's open for interpretation. She could have died. Her mother could have dragged her down to hell. She could have just simply made herself disappear to get away from the group.
You can't really tell. Is her final note a scream, or is she still singing? Who knows?
Can't pin me down When you play the game of thrones, you win or you die.
The witch's disappearance/"death" has been interpreted in quite a few different ways on the stage. In the original Broadway production, she gets lowered under the stage in a plume of smoke, while the revival had her fly in the air off the stage (and also had some important lyric changes.)
The movie is different in that she melts into the tar that the remaining characters use to trap the giantess. In the original production, they presumably get pitch leftover from when the prince trapped Cinderella on the stairs.
The way I've always liked to interpret it is that her mother's spell (which takes effect whenever she loses the magic beans) transforms her into something ugly. She sings to this effect, egging her mother on after she's thrown the beans, asking her to give her "claws or a hunch." However, she has no idea that her mother is upping the ante and turning her into something much more ugly. In the movie, I think it's apparent because Meryl Streep acts that part quite surprised as she melts, and the final note turns into a scream.
In the stage production, I've always liked to believe that she turns to dust, or even nothing at all. (What's uglier than something that doesn't exist?)
Of course, the revival suggested that throwing away the beans gave her back her powers, which is why she flies away, but I've never really liked that interpretation.
I think you may be thinking of how the Broadway revival handled the transformation, in which Vanessa Williams flew into the air and transformed. For her disappearance, she descended into the floor: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IEa599dP3Ck
In the Central Park revival, two arms came out of the ground and pulled Donna Murphy back down with her as Donna sang, "Mother, here I come!": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iFo_py7Kd_g
Umm... when did Vanessa Williams fly into the air? I only saw her descend into the floor like all the Witches have done in past productions. Also, I've never really taken to the revival changing the lyrics of Last Midnight.
"You better call my agent" "You don't have an agent..." "Then call my cable man!" - Bewitched (2005)
The thing is that the Witch has no purpose to live. She tries to convince the group to feed Jack to the Giantess, for that may keep Rapunzel safe, but when they refuse, she gets tired of their *beep* and loses it, conforming that she never belonged to the world and it's people and that she has no salvation. Her mother would curse her everytime she'd lose one of her magic beans, she then tosses them all on purpose so she'll 1) be cursed with age and ugliness and get her powers back, since she had lost them when she turned beautiful again, and flee the group and the Giantess, or 2) be punished with death or banishment by her mother's spirit for defying her orders once again. Which of these are the Witch's real intentions, and which of these actually happen to the Witch, is left to interpretation. The thing is that she wanted to get away from the people blaming her and from the Giantess, so she reenacted her mother's curse. When she sings "Alright, Mother, when?/Lost the beans again!/Punish me the way you did then!", it might mean she's actually asking for her later punishment (ugliness) but it could also be that she's just teasing her mother's spirit to level up her punishment to death.
I agree. What you said at the beginning about keeping Rapunzel safe was how I was justifying the Witch wanting to give Jack to the Giantess even though Rapunzel didn't die like in the original show. The Witch's eagerness to hand Jack over just doesn't make sense unless you decide that she is keeping Rapunzel safe from afar by making sure that the giantess leaves the kingdom - so that even though Rapunzel has rejected her mother, the Witch can still keep her safe.