MovieChat Forums > Into the Woods (2014) Discussion > Why Meryl and not bernadette?

Why Meryl and not bernadette?


Anyone know why bernadette couldn't reprise her role as the witch?

reply

They probably wanted a more well-known Hollywood name for the Witch to draw in crowds. Bernadette Peters is incredibly talented and a great performer, but she is mostly known for her stagework and isn't widely recognised outside of that sphere. It's a shame though :(

reply

As wonderful as Meryl was and as great a choice as I think she was, it would have been very interesting to see Bernadette take another crack at it. Perhaps it's time for another reunion concert!

reply

Me too! She rocked the role, since she originated it, and I would love to have seen the reunion concert live. Still, Meryl was great!

"You better call my agent" "You don't have an agent..." "Then call my cable man!" - Bewitched (2005)

reply

Meryl Streep is better. She's not as goofy as Bernadette. Meryl is more serious and wicked.

reply