Question to ponder...


Has anyone ever thought if Damian Echols was an absolute choirboy, was decent, normal, good grades, no Satanism, etc. would he ever have been implicated at all? Would the attention turn to Mark Byers and Terry Hobbs? Then THEY would be the subject of 4 documentaries.

Also, as to the question of Mr. Bojangles: While he spent time in the restaurant, did ever say anything to anybody?

If this case were handled very efficiently, competently, with John Douglas doing his thing from the get-go instead of 20 years later, would this be pretty much solved today? Example: no casts of footprints were taken by the dump site. The bodies should've been left until the ME showed up, the blood scraping on the restroom walls were processed correctly, etc.

Some days I think the WM3 are innocent, some days I feel they're guilty. Then back again. Ever feel that way too? Your thoughts?

reply

Well of course he wouldn't have been connected to the murders if he wasn't into the activities he was. I mean that's the very thing that led investigators TO him. That's like asking "If that guy wasn't driving, would he still have died in that wreck?" If Damien had been a different person, he would have been like any other citizen in West Memphis who wasn't a suspect. His activities are what started this whole thing.

reply

halcyonsummer is on point. Also I don't think this crime would have been solved either way. Outside of the botched evidence of the very strong Mr. Bojangles lead, the West Memphis police did a very good job with this case in my opinion.

reply

Wow...Most nons won't even say that. Have you even been to Callahan? The police botched one lead after another, losing evidence, not following up on tips, etc. Essentially the WMPD screwed up so bad, they had to pin what little evidence they could against the WM3.

reply

I'm not a non.

reply

[deleted]

Or maybe you could look it up yourself instead of acting like an asshat?

reply

[deleted]

I'm clueless when you apparently don't even know the basic general facts about this case.

reply

What evidence was there to tie into the WM3 exactly? a forced confession of a little boy who is supposedly borderline retarded? so called "satanic cults" is there any real evidence that Damien was actually a "satanist" at all instead of just a kid who was into normal dark teenage stuff like wearing black and listening to heavy metal music? oh and dark poetry.

reply

Ummm, sonofspam? Obviously you have not read up... Or you'd k now about a little document entitled "Exhibit 500..."

Damien was NOT just a weird kid who listened to Metallica and liked to make people think he was dark or whatever...

The dude was seriously *beep* up... He was a sick *beep*... That's all, thanks! ;)

reply

Ummm why don't you go *beep* yourself with a wooden spoon first off and second i read he supposedly had some mental issues but every interview i have seen of him he is lucid and intelligent.

reply

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAH "every interview he is lucid and intelligent..." NOOO! There's never been any seriously *beep* up, sociopaths, or psychopaths who gave completely lucid, and intelligent interviews! NEVER, I say, NEVER! Bahahahaha.

God... This just summed up most supporters in a nutshell...

So, you don't put any stock into his own mother saying she feared for her safety, and that of other children in the home?

Or the accounts of him sucking/licking blood from others? Or the other numerous accounts by various doctors, corrections officers, psychologists, etc. about his mental issues?

Nooo! That's just normal teenage stuff!

Or the accounts of him stomping a great dane to death? How could anybody stomp such a magnificent beast of an animal to death? Be a sick *beep* like Damien... Even if you discount this (which was accounted by Baldwin's cousin - you'd think his cousin wouldn't say something like this seeing as how his cousin was being tried right next to him - you cannot discount all of the aforementioned in E-500...

Face it - Damien was NOT just a weird teenager who stood out in a conservative redneck town... he was seriously *beep* in the head, and absolutely capable of acts of extreme violence (based on his own words, those of his mother, and those of numerous officials).

That's all... THANKS! ;) *waves*

reply

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAH "every interview he is lucid and intelligent..." NOOO! There's never been any seriously *beep* up, sociopaths, or psychopaths who gave completely lucid, and intelligent interviews! NEVER, I say, NEVER! Bahahahaha.

God... This just summed up most supporters in a nutshell...

So, you don't put any stock into his own mother saying she feared for her safety, and that of other children in the home?

Or the accounts of him sucking/licking blood from others? Or the other numerous accounts by various doctors, corrections officers, psychologists, etc. about his mental issues?

Nooo! That's just normal teenage stuff!


Most of what you are talking about is in exhibit 500, but you are pulling things a little out of context. Damien had issues, there is no denying that. When his Mother said she was scared of him, it was during one of his episodes. It wasn't like she constantly lived in fear of him.


Or the accounts of him stomping a great dane to death? How could anybody stomp such a magnificent beast of an animal to death? Be a sick *beep* like Damien... Even if you discount this (which was accounted by Baldwin's cousin - you'd think his cousin wouldn't say something like this seeing as how his cousin was being tried right next to him - you cannot discount all of the aforementioned in E-500...


http://callahan.8k.com/images2/joebar2.jpg

If memory serves, Joe Bartouch also told the police (at a later date) that not only could Damien levitate, but he had witnessed it first hand. Oh, also the police found 1 skull in their searches, not the large amount that Joe claims.


Face it - Damien was NOT just a weird teenager who stood out in a conservative redneck town... he was seriously *beep* in the head, and absolutely capable of acts of extreme violence (based on his own words, those of his mother, and those of numerous officials).

That's all... THANKS! ;) *waves*


Just curious where you interviewed Damien first hand, since you must be a licensed shrink to make statements like that.

reply

Well, my friend is a magician and he can make himself "levitate..." Hell, I can kinda do it myself! It's not hard to make the illusion of levitation after a bit of reading, and practice... I'm sure that's what he was referring to. Anyway, the story about him killing the great dane was corroborated by a few other girls? (Not 100% sure about this, though - it was either this particular incident, or other incidents of animal cruelty/killing).

The whole point of E-500 was to show that Damien had serious issues, and was 'bat *beep* crazy," if you will (so he wouldn't be put to death) - his own defense team presented all these documents compiled from medical records, records from correctional officers, psychologists, etc. Looking at these documents (no, I'm not a licensed shrink - but the ones making the diagnoses in E-500 are), you can see that Damien was absolutely capable of violence... Extreme, disturbing violence... Not normal teenage angst; not normal teenage anger, and aggression - yelling at your parents, simple fisticuffs, or getting in a fight with your dad tying to prove yourself as a "man."

Now, does E-500 PROVE he killed those three boys? Does it serve as evidence, per se, against him? Well, the answer is a resounding "NO," of course... However, it does buttress the fact he was a highly disturbed teenager, who was capable of extreme violence... It shows he was 100% capable of murder - including the capability to produce many of the wounds on the victims. He was the type who could lash out, and get out of control, and beat, and pound on three little boys with the blunt end of a knife, his fists, and sticks. He was the type who could mutilate body parts, and suck/lick blood...

You don't have to be a certified shrink, to read those documents and see Damien was not just a weird teenager who listened to Metallica and wore black... He had the mindset, and capability to engage in extreme violence. To say otherwise - that he was targeted for being a weird teenager in a redneck town is just not being truthful with yourself, nor others...

NOTE: That's the whole reason I bring this document up (and the statements of others, including his mother); I bring it up to disprove those (who likely have just seen the DOCUDRAMAS (not documentaries)), and maybe read a few biased articles from hollywood/mainstream media (who universally back him), that spread/uphold myths, and lies of Damien's mental health/state (at least at the time of the murders)... One of them being that he was just targeted because he was a weird teenager who went against the conservative, christian values/image in a backward, redneck town... There are MANY more myths, misconceptions, and lies that are propagated by the sheeple-lized mainstream... That I will continue to debunk, and set straight on as many mediums for case conversation as I can.

Another NOTE: I AM NOT a "sock puppet" of anybody else.. I am new to IMDb, but came here particularly to discuss these docudramas.

reply

[deleted]

I don't mean levitate as in raising yourself up on tiptoes, this guy said Damien floated/levitated around. The "girls" heard about the dog second hand btw.

As for Exhibit 500, let's look at the flip side of this.

Let's say a person...

1. Sexually assaulted an elderly neighbor.
2. Physically/sexually abused children.
3. Shot an unarmed man.
4. Moved away before the police could question him about the triple murders.
5. Was found to be in possession of a knife that one of the boys carried with him on the day of the murder.
6. Has no alibi for that night.
7. DNA similar to his was found at the crime scene.
8. Has been implicated in the murder by several people.

I just described Terry Hobbs. Now, you can use exhibit 500 against Damien all you want, but when compared to Hobbs he was a choir boy.

Just to set the record straight here, I do NOT believe Terry Hobbs was the killer. It's absolutely insane to me how many scumbags there were in West Memphis. You could throw a rock in that town and hit a dozen of them.

reply

[deleted]

Someones been drinking the kool aid too much methinks.

Where the hell did you get all this information about E-500 anyways? did you work there?

reply

The E-500 stuff you are talking about sounds like it was put out there by the defense team for an insanity defense because they could tell clearly these bunch of idiot rednecks where gonna throw him to the dogs.


I personally think it backfired tho and made him seem like someone who was so crazy he was really capable of killing three little kids for no reason.

reply

Jenkins - Hehe so far ole Putter seems OK... A bit out there like a lot of supporters are, but he seems to have at least studied and independently researched the case (unlike most who just have their "WWJDD" bracelets on - "What Would Johnny Depp Do")

Ive read your posts, though, and I can tell you're extremely learned regarding the case, and I agree with, and respect your opinion highly.

Heheh I will definitely look out for sock puppet accounts, and attacks!




Putter - We're not discussing Terry Hobbs background. The only reason I even bring up E-500 is to show people like Son of Spam that Damien was not just some "dark teenager who was targeted for being an outcast" - listening to Metallica, wearing black clothes, intentionally pissing off the conservative locals, etc. In fact, he exhibited behaviors found in many murderers, and moreover, behaviors that matched the MO of these particular murders (which I don't believe had much to do with the occult, or Satanism) - threats of violence/murder, licking/sucking blood, narcissistic personality/tendencies, and just in general a seriously mentally ill teenager who was clearly prone to extreme violence.




Son of Spam - I'm so familiar with E-500 because I have studied this case extensively, and thoroughly, and have reviewed the document on Callahans. It's all there for you to read yourself... Go on, actually take some self-initiative and do some independent research for yourself, and don't just believe what you hear about the case. As you can tell, the media, and hollywood is EXTREMELY biased...

In fact, I'm still waiting for some journalist to show some integrity and actually ask the guy some tough questions, and engage in real journalism, rather than just let Damien (and Jason too... lol they keep Jessie as far away from the cameras as possible) cover their own antics and then report it as credible journalism...

Here, I'll go ahead and do it for you and link you to the reports themselves (beware, there are HUNDREDS of files to go through), and for convenience sake, I'll link you to websites that sum them up (although I admit some of these websites ARE created by "non." But I can promise you can fact check yourself everything that is stated on callahans regarding this.)

Original documents at Callahan: http://callahan.8k.com/wm3/img/exh500.html

Here's a synopsis by a poster on a discussion board: http://westmemphishomicidesdiscussion.yuku.com/topic/5807/Exhibit-500Echols-Mental-HistoryViolence#.U17TUhzhjrB

You know what - there's a lot - just google "Exhibit 500 West Memphis Three Callahan"

And yes - you're exactly right - his defense team brought it into the sentencing phase to save his ass. Although maybe you'd like to address WHY exactly Damien and his homely looking broad Lorrie continue to lie and say it was concocted by some "mystery woman" who was out to get him (lol wut?) and she forges and lies... AND that it was brought up by Jason's lawyers to attack him... I seriously don't think they knew all of this information was out there, for everybody to see.. I don't know... But the guy lies about so many things regarding the case...

Oh yeah, people kill all the time on impulse, and just to satisfy sick, morbid curiosities.. I think that was mostly why Damien ring-led these murders... I also think he did somewhat want to satisfy some "occult" curiosities about "gaining power" (this is mentioned in his mental health records by a Dr. who hypothesizes where his violent tendencies come from)... And some other weird little fantasies, and ideas he had... But yes, people do kill people, even little boys, for no reason other than violent impulses, built up rage/anger, and curiosities.... Do some research... It's not the most common MO, but it definitely happens... Often by people who have mental health records similar to Damien

Happy reading... And when you're finished - please come back and tell me Damien was still just a "weird teenager who listened to Metallica and wore black." ;)





reply

Please do not cite the "yuku" boards as "fact". Anyway...

Putter - We're not discussing Terry Hobbs background. The only reason I even bring up E-500 is to show people like Son of Spam that Damien was not just some "dark teenager who was targeted for being an outcast" - listening to Metallica, wearing black clothes, intentionally pissing off the conservative locals, etc. In fact, he exhibited behaviors found in many murderers, and moreover, behaviors that matched the MO of these particular murders (which I don't believe had much to do with the occult, or Satanism) - threats of violence/murder, licking/sucking blood, narcissistic personality/tendencies, and just in general a seriously mentally ill teenager who was clearly prone to extreme violence.


The reason I brought up what Terry Hobbs has done (that we know about) is to show that there are people out there who are more suspect then Damien. Just about everyone can agree that Terry Hobbs is NOT a good person, right? This is why I keep saying that the WMPD botched things on this case. I would have LOVED to see the blood/mud scrapings from Bojangles get tested, frankly.

reply

[deleted]

I will do all the research you want but i have been in mental hospitals when i was a child and i know they exaggerate any problems or issues a kid has so they can get that money from the neurotic parents.

He may have been sick in the head and yet there is absolutely no evidence or proof that he killed those three kids or "masterminded" and that is all on the fault of the stupid dirty corrupt redneck police officers and whatever other authorities were over there.

and dont forget they all rushed to judgement on this case blaming Damien with no evidence besides the "satanic/occult ritual crime" which anybody with any common sense knows does not actually exist because first of all like Christianity there are dozens of different types of Satanists and they all don't agree or think the same thing and you can look up "satanic ritual" and it is classified as a moral panic and not something that really exists.


So wither Damien is or was sick in the head does not mean he did this crime that he was accused of.

reply

Putter - I was not citing the boards as fact - I was simply providing Son of Spam with places where some of the information from Callahan regarding E-500 was condensed... Callahan was cited document for document.... I think these websites like WM3 facts, yuku, Jive puppi (I know I said earlier that jive puppi was biased garbage, but as long as you fact check from Callahan, it can be helpful), etc. are great secondary sources if you know how to discriminate (i.e. fact check Callahan to ensure they are cited proper), because Callahan can be a bit overwhelming. While nothing substitutes taking the time to read everything on Callahan, some people don't have the time, so these websites that compile, condense, and organize documents from Callahan (in this case, E-500), make life easier at times...

I don't want to get into Hobbs here, because like I said, this thread was about Damien, and why he was a perfectly legitimate suspect, and has a background that suggests he's capable of murder. It was not used as evidence to show he DID commit the murders, because like I stated, E-500 is not evidence that he committed the murders, but merely to show that he WAS THE TYPE of person who was capable of committing the murders. Many people who listen to Damien and his chupacabras, or chalupas, as Trench calls them (quite humorously), buy into the fact he was just an average teenager who was a little dark, and weird, and stood out in his redneck hometown.

However, I'll go ahead and take the time to correct, or straight up debunk a few of your statements about Hobbs:

1.) Hobbs shot in self-defense a man who was attacking him in a rage. He did what most people would do if scared, and being attacked (and had a gun on them/in reach) - he reached for a gun and shot them. The force he used in self-defense was not the same level of force being used against him, but you make it out like he just shot some unarmed guy...

2.) Where is the proof he sexually abused children? The only people I've heard say this are hostile parties, and/or second, and thirdhand statements. Although, if I'm wrong here, please correct me (I have heard that he has a felony conviction on his record for something to do with a child, but again, nothing confirmed).
As far as physical abuse? The only believable info. I've heard is excerpt from Amanda's diary, and her statements about him "beating the hell out of her." Now would this count as child abuse? Or just being a strict, possibly even mean, father? Being spanked with a belt across the arse is not child abuse, IMO. I got whipped with a belt a few times as a kid, and I absolutely deserved it. I don't know why Amanda would be so friendly with him, and stick up for him on facebook (although Terry recently deactivated his account) if he was so horrible to her. Again, aside from second and thirdhand tales about Terry "beating" Stevie coming from hostile parties, there's nothing... Why would Pam continue to be married to the guy if she knew he was physically and/or sexually abusing Stevie? Why is she only coming out with it after they divorced and butting heads? Doesn't seem like something a mother would do if they really feared for their child like that.
However, if you have any credible sources of Terry sexually, or physically abusing children, let me know, and I'll stand corrected.

3.) There's nothing to prove Stevie was in possession of that knife the day of the murders. Just more *beep* from the drug-addled, abusing, hostile, and crazy Pam Hobbs. Absolutely nothing at all to prove this.

4.) He's only been implicated in the murder by convicted felons who actually are rapists... Haha and humorously, brought about by a lawyer with the surname "Swindle." Then the whole "Hobbs family secret" nonsense... If you can find any credibility whatsoever in this, I don't know how you can reject Jessie's confessions... Jessie had no reason to randomly implicate Damien and Jason - of all people, what are the chances he'd name two guys he wasn't even that good of friends with (who have no alibi). Jessie had no reason to randomly name them... These degenerate idiots have every reason to accuse Terry (money, attention, hatred of him, etc.) So yes, that is complete rubbish to "list" this... This thread didn't even have anything to do with the evidence against Damien, just his mental state to show that he was violent, and capable of violence, including murder.

So while Terry might have been an unscrupulous character, he certainly didn't have the sick mental health record of Damien, who was talking about killing people, and sucking/licking blood from people... You bringing up all this about Hobbs is not only irrelevant to Damien being a suspect, it still doesn't show Terry was "more capable" to murder than Damien. Terry could be violent, but not in the same sick way Damien was/could be. Because all that *beep* about Terry wasn't said until (conveniently) decades after the murders, by hostile parties. Many had motivation (financial, or other)....

I'm glad you don't believe Terry did it - those who do believe he did it are the ones who first accused Byers, and will eventually move on to probably start blaming some poor, old, homeless black fellow in the area as "Mr. Bojangles." Then they'll come full circle and blame Byers again...

There was definitely some unsavory folk in and around WM... But how many of them were implicated by a guy who confessed? How many had the recent mental history of Damien? How many did not have an alibi (yes, I know Terry doesn't have a complete alibi, but he can be accounted for shortly before, and after the murders took place, while Damien< jason and Jessie can't be accounted for all night)? How many had knives found in lakes behind their trailers that were capable of making an eerily similar wound-mark? It just gets to the point where you'd have to believe in a lot of coincidences to explain everything away...

BUT DAMN, all I wanted to do was show Damien was a legit suspect, as he should have been, because he was NOT just a "weird, dark, teenager."

reply

I was hoping you would be one of the few un-biased people here but you have proven that you are not by attacking Pam Hobs and excusing anything anything anyone else did that was against Damien and his friends.

Also Jessie implicated Damien and Jason because the police told him too DUH ! they knew they had no evidence against any of them so they went straight to the "borderline retarded" child (who is coincidentally the youngest of the three)the police officers picked Damien because of his satanic views which where abhorrent to that redneck bible belt thumping town.

Do you really want to believe that Damien could have masterminded this whole thing and get away with it yet bring along someone like Jessie who he must have known would fold like a paper tiger.

Or maybe he didn't know but obviously if he was capable of masterminding the murder of three boys with no witness's and no evidence you would think he would know who to trust and who to bring in with this conspiracy.

I also haven't seen any evidence that the other two boys were into the same occult weirdness and satanism.

I'm not going to point the finger at Hobbs or Byers completely even tho they both have more "evidence" against them than any of the boys.

Byers did not help his case at all with that over the top dramatic thing he did at the Robin Hood hills in the Paradise Lost movie and then removing all his teeth when the media were investigating bite marks not to mention he couldn't keep any of his stories straight about why he removed his teeth or anything else.

End Point We will never ever know what really happened and who did this because the police botched this case so badly and they and the other officials refuse to re-open this case because they don't want to look bad.

reply

I'm attacking what Pam has done, and her character as of late, moreso than her as a victim in this case too. I've been around the forums, and seen the garbage she posts... Some of the *beep* she says is revolting, and inexcusable.. She simply is not reliable - and to believe anything she says against Terry is foolish.

Not excusing anything anybody else did.. Just clearing it up, and putting it into perspective regarding the case.

I haven't seen anything where the cops "made" Jessie tab anybody, or made him say anything... And NO, he was not interrogated for 12 hours before "cracking." He was singing like a bird after 4 hours (another myth propagated out there). So, don't you find it coincidental than Damien and Jason have absolutely NO ALIBI whatsoever? None.

Again, Damien's behavior would be abhorrent to any normal person with any kind of scruples, or morals (not religious in nature). That's what you seem to be missing here... Which is why I went on about E-500 - so you could get into his mind, and understand what a sick, twisted little *beep* he was.

He didn't mastermind *beep* It was a random encounter, and what turned into random acts of violence, gradually escalating.

Jessie had a record of violence, and was prone to violent outbursts... Jason was your typical effeminate, limp-wristed beta male follower... He'd do whatever Damien wanted.

There is plenty of evidence against the three... Plenty more than there is against either Hobbs, or Byers... At least Byers took and passed a polygraph test - more than Damien can say (he failed a polygraph test). I'd point you to Callahan again, but I'd suggest giong to WM3facts to see ALL the evidence there is against them... Yes, this is a somewhat "biased" ste as it's run by nons, but EVERYTHING they lay out are nothing more than known facts about the case (cited at Callahan from case documents, etc.) Go read up, and tell me there's more evidence against Byers, and Hobbs than the three....

Byers is a volatile and eccentric character... I can't help but to wish him the best, even though he's a bit loose in the head... Terry is just a victim as much as anybody else, and needs to be left the F alone... Just another "red herring" like Byers... And eventually somebody else will be...

The police could have done a better job, but in most investigations the cops usually can. But hindsight is 20/20, and at the time, they pursued the leads they had, and eventually got their guys... The case is CLOSED, and the three have PLEAD GUILTY to murder (thrice), after being convicted by two juries. They are not exonerated, and the case is not "open." It's a wrap... Three guilty, convicted child killers (thrice) 4-life... Damn shame they're not rotting in prison still, but in this country if you throw enough money, and enough *beep* at the wall, eventually you'll get something to stick in the minds of the sheeple.

reply

Wow i don't have time to sit here and rebut everything you say but you are clearly biased (at least i admit that i am because i can relate to Damien but that doesn't mean i would excuse him if he did commit these murders) you make excuses for all the accused fathers when in actuality they would be the first person's likely to do this sort of thing but alas the police where to busy looking at a couple of kids (it seems because of Damien's reputation and Jerry Drivers obsession with him and his "satanism) and yes i agree the three boys don't seem to have a clear alibi but when has that ever mattered to police?

Jessie Misskelley was interrogated for hours but yet the tape recorder seemed to be off most of the time for some reason.

The fact that you throw Pam Hobbs under the bus and call her all these names but you will make any excuse for the three fathers shows to me that you have a clear bias.

reply

The issue I have is that you keep saying that due to E-500, that proves that Damien is a psycho. I pointed out worse offenses carried out by Terry Hobbs and you swept them under the rug or flat out denied them. Let's go through your rebuttal really quick.

1.) Hobbs shot in self-defense a man who was attacking him in a rage. He did what most people would do if scared, and being attacked (and had a gun on them/in reach) - he reached for a gun and shot them. The force he used in self-defense was not the same level of force being used against him, but you make it out like he just shot some unarmed guy...


Do you know why this all happened? Terry was beating up Pam and she called her Dad and brother to come and help her out. Jackie Jr. showed up, saw what Terry did to his sister and proceeded to alley stomp him, Terry in turn grabbed a gun and shot Jackie Jr. See, to a scumbag like Terry, it's ok to beat on women but when you are on the losing edge of things you do whatever it takes. It's not a matter of self-defense, this shows malice to me, that Terry is capable of killing someone.

2.) Where is the proof he sexually abused children? The only people I've heard say this are hostile parties, and/or second, and thirdhand statements. Although, if I'm wrong here, please correct me (I have heard that he has a felony conviction on his record for something to do with a child, but again, nothing confirmed).
As far as physical abuse? The only believable info. I've heard is excerpt from Amanda's diary, and her statements about him "beating the hell out of her." Now would this count as child abuse? Or just being a strict, possibly even mean, father? Being spanked with a belt across the arse is not child abuse, IMO. I got whipped with a belt a few times as a kid, and I absolutely deserved it. I don't know why Amanda would be so friendly with him, and stick up for him on facebook (although Terry recently deactivated his account) if he was so horrible to her. Again, aside from second and thirdhand tales about Terry "beating" Stevie coming from hostile parties, there's nothing... Why would Pam continue to be married to the guy if she knew he was physically and/or sexually abusing Stevie? Why is she only coming out with it after they divorced and butting heads? Doesn't seem like something a mother would do if they really feared for their child like that.
However, if you have any credible sources of Terry sexually, or physically abusing children, let me know, and I'll stand corrected.


Amanda's leaked diary talks about it. I have always wondered if the "David" she mentions is Jacoby. Here is a link.

http://i38.photobucket.com/albums/e142/obscuregawdess/a2.jpg

Also, several of Pams family have come out and said what they had seen. Why would Pam stay with him? Why do most abused women stay with their husbands? As for Amanda sticking up for him on Facebook, let me tell you a quick story. There used to be a guy here named Mojo who ran a WM3 board called downatthefarm or downonthefarm or some such. He constantly bragged about people being directly involved in this case being members of his board. When the WM3 were released he claimed that Amanda said she was very upset about the release of the 3 and if memory serves "she" hinted around to violence against the WM3. Then I posted a picture of Amanda Hobbs and Jason Baldwin together, smiling and questioned the people on his board, very shortly after that he deleted his entire board and left the imdb forums too. So forgive me if I have a hard time when someone on FB who is claiming to be Amanda says something supporting nons/pros.

Oh, also keep in mind that Terry sexually assaulted Mildred French too, that doesn't really help his situation. So now we know he is capable of shooting someone and sexually assaulting someone.

3.) There's nothing to prove Stevie was in possession of that knife the day of the murders. Just more *beep* from the drug-addled, abusing, hostile, and crazy Pam Hobbs. Absolutely nothing at all to prove this.


Right here you lost all credibility. To say that Pam is a "drug-addled, abusing, hostile and crazy" person, but believe that Terry Hobbs is not, that just is scary.

4.) He's only been implicated in the murder by convicted felons who actually are rapists... Haha and humorously, brought about by a lawyer with the surname "Swindle." Then the whole "Hobbs family secret" nonsense... If you can find any credibility whatsoever in this, I don't know how you can reject Jessie's confessions... Jessie had no reason to randomly implicate Damien and Jason - of all people, what are the chances he'd name two guys he wasn't even that good of friends with (who have no alibi). Jessie had no reason to randomly name them... These degenerate idiots have every reason to accuse Terry (money, attention, hatred of him, etc.) So yes, that is complete rubbish to "list" this... This thread didn't even have anything to do with the evidence against Damien, just his mental state to show that he was violent, and capable of violence, including murder.


Argh, the confessions. It would be easier to take the confessions seriously if any of them matched one another or had actual facts involved with them. Everyone has different details but they all have the same outcome that the 3 boys were dead at the end.

This is typical on this board of how it goes about those.

Nons - "He confessed at least 4 times (unless your are Jenkim, then you claim 5-9 times).

Supporters - "But in all of his confessions, the "facts" are completely wrong, there isn't anything supporting the crime other then the 3 little boys are dead."

Nons - "The whiskey bottle says it all!"

Supporters - "The whiskey bottle wasn't even mentioned until the last confession and it wasn't even part of the murder, further more there is no proof that it was even purchased that day or drank that day. It's not evidence, it's coincidence."

Nons - "Yeah, but he confessed that is all that matters."

Supporters - "What about the other 2 guys who confessed right after the murders. You know, the ones who were familiar with the victims, who moved to California within days of the murders, who failed polygraphs from a TRAINED polygraph administer?"

Nons - "Doesn't matter, Jessie confessed."

reply

And year people never falsely confess under police interrogation right? that never happens (sarcasm)

The big problem is that everyone involved in this case no matter how small seems to have three different stories or the stories have changed and this is includes all sides.

reply

I am fairly new to these incidents, and I have only read about the first 30 pages of E-500, but it's such a mess of stories and notes that I don't think you can really get a reliable idea about Damien's psyche from this, certainly not that he is a killer. He was obviously a troubled young man, and I agree that I think the documentaries really are misleading in downplaying this fact.

However, I also think that branding someone as a killer because they have mental issues is the same kind of fear-fueled prejudice as saying they are a killer because they wear black and listen to Metallica. Psychiatry and psychology are very inexact sciences that require constant consultation and analysis over long periods of time, and even then the therapist can be biased or skewed.

I understand there are other reasons to believe they are guilty, but trying to diagnose someone as capable of murder based on that mess of conflicted notes is plain prejudice. Yes, in a tiny number of cases mental illness is connected to violence, but that is a small number of violent crimes and of the mentally disabled population, something like less than 5%. Most violent crime is committed by "sane" people.

I know people who have gone through similar things, yes even things like killing animals or sucking blood, but in no way would I leap to the conclusion that they were a murderer. Killing animals is unfortunately pretty acceptable to a lot of people, as sick as I think it is, I'm 90% vegan in fact. They might even have pets and seemingly love them, but admit in the past to torturing or killing animals. Many of the claims in the E-500 are not confirmed, and could have been lies told by the parents or girlfriend's family, and the compiler notes the factual errors several times (dates, ages, etc.) in the original records. Damien denies feeling violent several times, while expressing violent thoughts at others. Also, the daughter claims the stepfather sexually abused her, even though he and the mother claim this isn't true. And with that kind of turmoil going on, whatever the reality, is it any wonder that this was a tumultuous household, or that Damien was troubled? The thing that came up again and again was suicidal ideation, and I think at one point his diagnosis was Depressive Disorder, with elements of Narcissistic Disorder.

And I got this from the first 30 items. Of course, the heavily biased Yuki site summary leaves all this out.

Even given the idea that based on the mental health history, Damien seems to be the "type" who could have done it, the records indicate a high level of impulsivity, that's why he kept getting in trouble. This would make it very unlikely for him to be able to make the crime scene as clean as it was, to wash away DNA evidence, the blood, etc.

Anyway, as I initially said, I'm not speaking from extensive knowledge of the case, but I felt someone should say something against the bias against mental illness by connecting it with violent crime.

"every time godzilla loses to mothra I die a little bit more"--Godzillaswrath

reply

I read Amanda's diary excerpts, and she explicitly says "I don't remember my dad sexually abusing me..." She pontificates a bit, but that's not enough for you to say matter of factly that "Terry sexually abused children."

Umm, you realize the amount of people who make false confessions are nowhere close to the amount of those who are actually guilty? Yeah, it happens more than it should, but still, the odds are overwhelmingly against you on this one. Lol, you're throwing it out there like it's 50/50 chance that a confession is false LOL.



For the last time: (yes, I'm going to caps lock this because you lot seem to be missing it): I AM NOT SAYING HIS DISTURBING MENTAL HEALTH HISTORY (AND ACTS OF VIOLENCE, DRINKING BLOOD, LICKING BLOOD) PROVE HE DID IT. NOT EVEN CLOSE; I'M GOING SO FAR AS TO SAY IT IS NOT EVIDENCE IN THE LEAST (TO BE USED AGAINST HIM REGARDING HIM COMMITTING THE MURDERS). I SIMPLY POINT IT OUT TO CORRECT THE MISCONCEPTIONS THAT DAMIEN WAS JUST SOME WEIRD KID... ALL IT DOES FOR ME, IS SHOW THAT HE IS CAPABLE OF MURDER - BECAUSE HE WAS NOT JUST OFF HIS ROCKER, HE WAS VIOLENT.

Is that cleared up, now? Can we stop acting like I'm saying it should be used as evidence against him?

reply

Were you replying to me, or someone else? Because I didn't mention anything about Terry Hobbs or false confessions. When I mentioned sexual abuse, that was recorded about Damien's sister against their stepfather. That was referenced early on in E-500.

And if you read my post closely, I am not objecting to the idea that Damien's mental health problems constitute proof--I realize you're not saying that, and that's why I mentioned I know there are other things you do believe prove them guilty. But I do object to the idea that a history of mental health issues--even ones as seemingly troubling as Damien's--indicates one is capable of murder. It's part of prejudice against the mentally disabled that is just as insidious as the "satanic panic," if not more so because these reflect actual problems faced by actual people. Especially given the problems with E-500 that I point out above.

I'm not saying there's never a correlation between mental illness and violent crime, but it's a stigma that such a correlation is likely, when most violent crime is committed by supposedly sane people.

"every time godzilla loses to mothra I die a little bit more"--Godzillaswrath

reply