MovieChat Forums > Spectral (2016) Discussion > Can it be so hard to make some new stori...

Can it be so hard to make some new stories?


As everyone has pointed out the movie has similarities to a FF movie and Aliens. For me it's not the end of the world, I like Aliens and the it's gritty mood(I also know Aliens copied Them!, but dosen't change my question really, since the same goes for them).

But if you spend $50-$100m why can't they come up with a more unique script? It can't be THAT hard?

reply

Can you think of a movie that you can say is 100% original?

As everyone has pointed out the movie has similarities to a FF movie and Aliens.


And Final Fantasy: Spirits Within has similarities to Aliens too. Plus, like someone pointed out, creatures in this and Spirits Within are kind of similar to a cloud creature from an episode of Star Trek.

reply

It's not that they CAN'T come up with something more original, it's that they often WON'T risk tens of millions of dollarsworth of investment on something untested. Hollywood is a business and that business isn't to entertain you with original stories... it's to take your money.

reply

Same reason Apple comes out with 7 versions of iPhone that are barely different from the version before it. It's a business to make money, as soon as the iPhone sales lag they will create something new.

When remakes and squeals stop making money they will push more innovative things. It's also risky, as Pixanaut says. That's a lot of money to risk on an unknown, original idea. One would say Cloud Atlas was original, but they lost a lot of money on it.

reply