MovieChat Forums > Spectral (2016) Discussion > Russian border of Moldova? Someone needs...

Russian border of Moldova? Someone needs to get a map out!


I literally got 10 minutes into this thing and one character said something like "most of those forces are up north near the Russian border". I'm like "WTF!?!?! These people couldn't be bothered to check a map when they wrote this?".

Moldova's northern border is with Ukraine. Which is NOT Russia and I don't think they would appreciate it being referred to like that. Maybe the movie exists in some hypothetical future where Russia has reclaimed much of Ukraine, but I don't recall anyone saying this.

I really don't get how details like this make it into a script when it only takes 30 seconds to Google this stuff.

reply

[deleted]

It is full of localization errors.

1. Early in the movie, the CIA agent asks the child a question in broken Romanian. She answers in perfect Russian. Moldova was both Russian and Romanian but the language spoken is a Romanian dialect. In any case, nobody speaks perfect Russian anymore.

2. Later in the movie, everyone has perfect Romanian. Nobody speaks like that in Moldova.

3. It is no surprise that it is filmed in Budapest and set in Moldova but the problem is that they look nothing alike Budapest is one of the most recognizable European capitals and it is in Central Europe, not Eastern Europe. This means that the style, the designs, most elements, are different.

4. Moldova also happens to be one of the poorest countries in Europe according to Numbeo so I don't see how they can develop superweapons.

I haven't paid close attention but I think they got the physics part wrong too. Now, for 70% of the world that doesn't live in Europe nor has visited Europe, this means nothing at all. They could speak in Mandarin and it would have been the same thing. However, as someone who knows Romanian and some Russian, it was a "WTF" moment. The same can be said with the border - last time Moldova had a border with Russia was during the URSS, when, as far as I recall, Moldova was part of it.

There are many WTF moments and I'm curious about the state of aggregation. I understand that it is a sci-fi movie but you can invent stuff only so far.

reply

[deleted]

And his other points?

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

I find it hard to understand why they have to pretend it's a different city, especially when they play it in a city that immediately reveals where they actually are.
25 minutes into when they leave in the convoy and filmed from the air, they drive past St. Stephen's Basilica (church). Why not simply let the movie take place in Budapest when it's where they are filming it?

reply

The little girl spoke Slovenian, as did the CIA agent later on - maybe also at the start of the movie but she was butchering the language so much that I had a hard time understanding anything and I was born in Slovenia. The girl on the other hand spoke almost perfectly so I went to check her imdb profile and it turned out her mother is from here which explains why she got the accent and everything right. Also, even the script had them (little girl and her brother) say that they're from Slovenia ("Slovenca sva". What they were doing in Moldova is anyone's guess though, but I got the impression that the director tried to show them as locals which makes no sense.

reply

producers, casting directors.. etc will always do that. get people from all over the place and make them act as something they are not. i'm colombian and that 'narcos' series is a perfect example.

reply

The little girl spoke Slovenian, as did the CIA agent later on


yes, emily mortimer speaking slovenian sounded like it had russian accent, i know, because one russian who now lives in slovenia, sounds a lot like that...

basically she didn't pronounce it correctly so it sounded very weird & funny 

not that i mind, but why were the characters slovenians, and not moldovan?


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LR76xcQ5lPA

reply

The children were speaking perfect Slovene, which is quite different from Russian.

reply

Not that is matters that much for the story of the movie, but Hungary is indeed generally considered part of Eastern Europe - especially from an east/west perspective. I.e. definitely more Eastern than Western Europe.

This has more to do with history and politics than with pure geography, and since Hungary has a history of being a communist state of Russia and the Soviet Union, it clearly qualifies as an Eastern European country.

reply

Oh, and also...the ghosts aren't real. :Rolleyes:

reply