MovieChat Forums > Upstream Color (2013) Discussion > Shane Carruth is a genius!

Shane Carruth is a genius!


Just kidding.

I usually go with the old Jewish policy of "three strikes and you're out", but with Carruth I am giving up after his second incoherent installment. Carruth cannot act, nor apparently, write. Plants, worms, water, bank, blood, trains, pigs and ankle herpes. Sorry for all the "spoilers".

Some view this movie as deep. As deep and substantial as a Great Dane's steaming pile. No thanks. You have been warned.

That is all.

reply

I absolutely love it, and I'm not making that up or trying to love it.

There's a lot of brilliant ideas going on within.

reply

Gotta love you man. Because you couldn't figure it out, no one can! You're the world's smartest human being!

I bet you don't understand Bell's Theorem and quantum entanglement, either, so I suppose that's all a pile of dog turd, too, rather than the most important scientific discovery since Einstein.

It's kind of frightening that people are so insecure about their intelligence that they take this attitude towards films they can't figure out. Folks who would have no difficulty admitting that they're not smart enough to be a nuclear engineer or write an OS for a computer can't stomach the idea that there are films they can't understand. And so they furthermore feel the need to assert or imply that the people who do claim to understand them are liars, frauds, poseurs, or whatever.

For the record, I think this is one of the two best ordinary-length films ever made. (The other is A Separation.)

Prepare your minds for a new scale of physical, scientific values, gentlemen.

reply

Thanks for loving me. Care to offer a brief explanation of this film? Simple enough for a dipsquat to understand.



"I'm so dumb, I'll probably vote for Trump"

reply

Emvan,
I'm going to go with Cocksure here, and ask you for a brief explanation of the film. Just throw us a frickin' bone here.

Thanks from the great unwashed masses of film nerds.




Schrodinger's cat walks into a bar, and / or doesn't.

reply

The main difference between smart people and dumb people is that smart people recognize their own stupidity.

reply

I loved Upstream Color, but I love it even more that people couldn't finished it and/or hated it.





Enjoy these words, for one day they'll be gone... All of them.

reply

It was very weird the first time. Not what I expected at all. (I had an early copy of his script for Topiary). But, it made me think about it, the cycle, the thief, the worm, the ending. I went back and rewatched it. I admire the depth he put into the story. Shane is a great writer, not an actor, not a director. He has a good eye for camera angles.

And I will go to his next film, even though it sounds like something I won't like. I know I'll be surprised.

reply

Well said, TA. Well said.



Enjoy these words, for one day they'll be gone... All of them.

reply