Interesting to see those two films mentioned in the same breath as, theoretically, they should be complementary viewing experiences: two halves of the same story.
Which made me think: "The Imitation Game" and "U-571" say something fairly profound about the British and American "national psyches", respectively. They're two very different films, but they have a lot in common, i.e. they're both set in WW2, and both deal (in their own way) with a chapter of the Enigma machine story.
Neither film is entirely historically accurate (to put it mildly!) but it's the ways in which they fictionalise their historical subjects that are telling.
"The Imitation Game" amplifies the importance of Turing's contribution, and our sympathies for him, not in order to make British audiences go "Yay Britain!" but in order to make audiences feel more keenly the unjust and ungrateful treatment he received post-war from the country he had served. An understated and ultimately tragic film.
"U-571", on the other hand, rewrites history in order to place fictional American heroes in a scenario that was a real-life British victory. It goes beyond being merely offensive, and comes off as a jaw-droppingly insensitive piece of delusional national narcissism. An overstated, bombastic film.
The British excel at self-flagellation.
The Americans excel at self-aggrandisement.
We knew that already, of course, but it's interesting to note how these two films, with their dovetailing subject-matter, differ in tone so radically and reflect the national psyches of the countries that produced them.
reply
share