As I understand it now...


From looking at a number of boards and seeing what they did, if you wanted to call it a homage or "based on" you might be able to pull it off. Apparently this take is a post apocalyptic world in the year 825 (?) and the defenders are in Japan in the last walled city holding out against the titans. Oh yes, they can use weapons like RPGs now too! I think the best laugh I got was from a poster on another board who had this to say about the thinking process that went into the making of the film:

"PraetorBrian Ashcraft
4/22/15 9:37am
I feel like the thought process was probably like this:

Hmm, let’s make a movie that will make lots of money. We’re pretty conservative, so it also has to be a sure thing. That means we have to make a movie based on something that is currently really popular, and then spend only as much as is absolutely necessary to ensure a profit. What’s really popular right now?
Attack on Titan.
Okay, let’s do that. Tell me about it.
It’s a manga/anime, set in early 19th century Europe...
Great, let’s base it in modern Japan. We’ll only use Asian actors too.
...well, um, hmm. Anyway, humanity has been reduced to a single huge city with 3 concentric ring walls around it. All their farming and food production and industry and everything is contained within those walls.
Great, we’re in Tokyo, we’ll base it in Tokyo.
There’s not a lot of farmland in Tokyo...
CG.
Okay.
So what’s the conflict? Where’s the drama!?
Well, these huge, non-communicative humanoid things called titans try to eat the humans, hence the walls, but the brave, adventurous, cavalier defenders of the city in the Survey Corp regularly venture outside the walls to learn more about the titans and how to defeat them. Again, this is based roughly on early 19th century Europe, so they ride horses and carry swords. The city walls are manned with cannons.
Great, let’s toss some RPGs and Stinger missiles in there, it’ll be great!"

O-K-A-Y...

reply

"Apparently this take is a post apocalyptic world in the year 825 (?) "

It takes place 2000 years in the FUTURE. This mistake comes from a wide misunderstanding of the title of the first Anime episode: "To You, 2,000 Years in the Future -The Fall of Zhiganshina Part 1"

The problem is --- who is speaking to who? Most people read this as THEM speaking to US, but if you instead read this as US speaking to THEM things start to clear up. There is simply no way that this story can take place in the past, unless it is on a completely different planet. How can i be so sure? Because the story is about ALL of humanity being walled in together and interbreeding. The movie of course is virtually all Japanese people but that's just because movies are harder to cast than anime.  Many of the characters still have very Germanic names. Just take a look at the list of characters on the info page. And what kind of name is Keith Shardis, the head instructor of the 104th Trainees Squad?

"So what’s the conflict? Where’s the drama!? "

Most of the conflict and drama are based on human relations in this story -- what to do with refugees, class power struggles and lots and lots of .... secrets ...

The movie will not have enough time to reveal the mystery behind the titans, but you can always watch the anime (season one) and the Manga is already on what would be the equivalent of a third movie.

I have no idea how good the movie will be, but i am hooked on the anime and manga. This is a great story.

reply

If you want to see what happens when you make a lot of changes from the original story, read the comments on the live action Patlabor films:

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt2789534/?ref_=fn_al_tt_3

Or would you prefer The Rose of Versailles, filmed with an all Japanese cast wearing wigs? Suspension of disbelief is something else...

Yeah, the source material for AoT is pretty good but the execution on this film may be questionable, especially since they have the budget to do an International production (but aren't). A pity and another lost opportunity IMO...

The year is given but its not the Roman Calendar. It's more like Gundam's Universal Century calendar, made up for the sake of the story. But making all these other changes like allowing much more (to us) modern weaponry like RPGs and Stinger missles? Geez, why not throw in some tanks to boot? Not getting a good vibe from this at all but it might end up being an okay popcorn flick. Time will tell...

reply