MovieChat Forums > Shingeki no kyojin (2015) Discussion > Very bad movie. Unfaithful to story.

Very bad movie. Unfaithful to story.


Where to begin. This is a big WHAT THE ____??

FIrst, the movie covers the first 8 episodes of the anime. Not the first 17 (Female Titan). I guess i was stupid for believing such a rumor.

Still ... there is plenty to cover in the first 8 episodes, but the producers instead decided to change the story and the characters. Must time is wasted on relations that have nothing to do with the original story and on top of that, they go nowhere. That time could have been devoted to the real story of "Shingeki no kyojin."

This is not the same story. REPEAT. This is not the same story.


There is no Eren's mother. There is no Titan that eats Eren's mother.
The intro cartoon shows humans building the wall.
Armin gets no attention other than getting bullied.
There is no attention to the Survey Corps. There is no training.
Mikasa essentially replaces Eren's mother (she disappears at the beginning).
Mikasa returns as the lover of some replacement of Levi.
Eren is jealous of this.
There is no back story to Mikasa's scarf other than Eren just sort of gives it to her in a flashback.
The Titans laugh. Loudly.
The Colossal titan looks fine, but not only do we not see his return, he kicks in the wall. Not the gate.
They all salute weakly. Almost like Connie does before Keith rips him a new one.

And most importantly. There is no Keith Shardis, Dot Pixis, Erwin, Connie, Bertold, Reiner nor even Annie. There is a giant Eren and he uses Annie's kick, but there is no Annie to use it on him first. Oh by the way ... Eren's father apparently is eaten in the first attack. "Hey Main Character! Isn't that your father being eaten by that titan?" (cut to some man being eaten by some titan).


Sorry, but this sucks the Donkey Balls. A few of the scenes are well realized, but who cares at this point?

This is not "Shingeki no kyojin." Those are like, other kids ... or something. Huh huh.

3/10

p.s. I was introduced to this story several months ago via the trailer for the live action movie. Rather than wait for the movie, i watched the anime and read the manga.

anime 10/10
manga 10/10

reply

Bump. Apparently the paid shills are here at this board to trick you into wasting your money on it.

If you are a fan of the anime/manga, you have been warned.

reply

how much of a fangirlie troll are you?

a) a lot
b) a lot
c) a lot

choose wisely

Please allow me to introduce myself
I'm a man of wealth and taste

reply

Bump. Apparently the paid shills are here at this board to trick you into wasting your money on it.

If you are a fan of the anime/manga, you have been warned.

You love the anime so much you should be happy there are people who might like the movies, regardless of what you think of them personally. Why? Because it can be a gateway to exploring other ATTACK ON TITAN related media. They may even end up liking the anime as well.

DRAGONBALL EVOLUTION (2009) is a pop culture poria, but it led me to seek out the original anime on DVD. And you know what? It is better. DRAGON BALL Z is also great. DRAGON BALL GT was pretty decent. I have yet to see DRAGON BALL SUPER, but if it's ever dubbed in English, I wouldn't rule it out.


http://www.freewebs.com/demonictoys/

reply

bump (just to irk the shills some more)

reply

That was Armin's dad that was eaten in the beginning.

Eren's parents were both killed when he was too young to remember. According to the movie.

reply

This movie really sucked.

reply

[deleted]

I didn't feel any suckage from it. 

Please allow me to introduce myself
I'm a man of wealth and taste

reply

This movie still sucks. The rating is still 5/10. All the shills can do is create fake accounts and post fake reviews and fake message board threads.

reply

5/10 isn't low enough? considering many people won't bother with an animation if there's a live-action. it sucks but that does tip the scales a lot. also it's imdb, everyone knows to take number ratings with a grain of salt anyway.

Plot hole - Aspect of a film that is misunderstood or missed while using your smart phone.

reply

The rating is still 5/10.

That's two ratings higher than what you gave it in your original post.


http://www.freewebs.com/demonictoys/

reply

i was reading chapter 80 today and suddenly i felt the urge to watch this live action
oh boy what a mistake...

the moment i saw this mikasa out of character the moment i close the player

reply

Lol, what a pathetic dude. Investing so much time in something you didn't like. Get over it.

reply

"Get over it." 

Get over yourself. 5.1 ... you guys gained 0.1 ... 

reply

THERE IS BEARLY ANY DIALOUGE IN THE MOVIE. TERRIBLE. JUST LIKE THE DEATH NOTE LIVE ACTION MOVIE

reply